I'm Your Boy Toy

8 Jul 2021 Score 57 / 100 imyourboytoy.com Mobile friendly


  • Videos 4 stars
  • Pictures 4 stars
  • Unique 4 stars
  • Size 2 stars
Review score 57
  • 3 stars Cost
  • 0 stars Updates
  • 4 stars Usability
  • 3 stars Claims
ImYourBoyToy tour page Click here to visit I'm Your Boy Toy

Introduction to imyourboytoy.com

Slender twinks and horny boys 18 to 25 in suck and fuck daddy/boy sessions with older men in their thirties and forties. Lots of rimming and messy cumshots, plus some interviews. 88 videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobile, and each comes with a set of pics. Site no longer updates, but members get access to a network of gay porn sites with over 900 bonus videos.

Skip to full review

Since Last Review

  • Site has added 2 videos
  • Site has added interview videos to the main video listing
  • Site stopped updating

ImYourBoyToy Topics

Video info

Videos offered for download and streaming

88 videos in MP4 format, a mix of full scenes and interview videos. Largest sized at 1920x1080 at good amateur quality or better, 3 smaller sizes available. Streaming, mobile compatible videos also available. No DRM used.

Picture info

42 picture sets (1 for each action video). Most pictures are good amateur quality digital stills sized at around 667x1000. Zip files available, no slideshows. Pics can be individually downloaded.

Bonus content

11 bonus sites and collections from the same network.

Site issues

This site no longer updates!

Site does not update. Pre-checked offer (called a cross sale) on right side of billing page. Trial members get limited access; they can only watch the network's 3 latest scenes. By joining, you automatically agree to receive commercial emails.

Membership cost of I'm Your Boy Toy

Trial membership only gives you limited access. There are pre-checked options on signup page. If left checked, you will automatically be subscribed to another site.

  • Trial: $1.95 (recurring at $24.95 every 30 days)
  • Trial: $4.95 (recurring at $24.95 every 30 days)
  • Monthly: $24.95 (recurring every 30 days)
  • Quarterly: $49.95 (recurring every 90 days)

I'm Your Boy Toy Review

I'm Your Boy Toy focuses on horny boys from 18 to around 25 getting nailed by men in their thirties and daddies aged forty or a little older. The boys are mostly smooth, slender, and many are twinks, although some are more "regular" guy types. They're partnered with men in their prime, many of whom are sexy, bearded hunks with great bodies including some with hairy chests and asses. Daddies include very sexy porn star Marcus Ruhl, salt and pepper bearded daddy Mike Manchester, bald and hairy Adam Russo, and masculine star Dominic Pacifico, while some of the twinks are well-known performers like sexy Brit Skylar Blu, super cute Kyler Moss, and slim Titus Snow. There are also some lesser-known faces.

The set-ups here are fairly minimal and get us right into the action. A bearded teacher comes by to hook up with the college student he used to fuck, and as soon as we establish that mom is out, the kissing begins. A married man sneaks around with a horny twink for some fun on the side and they get right to the dick sucking. Or in a bit of a role reversal, a cocky twink goes out to catch some rays by his family's pool, and the muscular man cleaning the pool (Marcus Ruhl) asks him if he wants to fuck; soon the guys are trading blowjobs, then Marcus gets his ass eaten and takes the twink's cock up his ass. And sometimes there's no set-up at all: the start of one video has a pantless Hans Berlin on his knees in front of a not-yet-naked Titus Snow.

I'm Your Boy Toy offers 88 DRM-free videos in MP4 format, a mix of full scenes and interview videos. The largest downloads are sized at 1920x1080 at good amateur quality or better, and there are also three smaller sizes, including a smaller HD version at 1280x720 and two standard sizes that should work for most mobiles. The videos can also be streamed on your desktop and mobiles, and the larger sizes look good at full screen.

Each sex scene comes with a set of pictures. These are good amateur quality digital stills that are sharp and clear, sized at around 667x1000, although they could have been a little better lit. Each set can be downloaded in a zip file or you can save the images you like individually. There are no slideshows, but you can navigate from pic to pic easily.

I'm Your Boy Toy members get access to six bonus sites and five bonus video collections offering 960 additional videos, and the network adds three new videos per week. One of the sites, Bang Me Sugar Daddy, also features twinks with guys in their thirties and forties, and while this site no longer updates, there are 52 videos. There's also My Gay Boss and My Husband is Gay as well as more sites including the two newest (and smallest) sites, Boys That Gagged and Hard Issues.

The site does have some downsides. First is that I'm Your Boy Toy stopped updating at the end of August, 2017, so what you see is what you get; some of the bonus sites don't update, either. Next is the pre-checked offer on the right side of the billing page, but it's easy to uncheck if you're not interested. Trial members get limited access; they can view the network's latest three full scenes. By joining, you automatically agree to receive commercial emails with no way to opt out at that time. There's are rows of thumbs at the bottom of every page that lead to a third-party cam site.

Something I did want to mention is that the cutest twinks and hottest daddy/boy pairings are in the older content from 2013 and before. Not only is that my opinion, but sorting the site videos by "highest rated" (by users) gives you videos from the same time frame. Still, you can preview all the videos on the tour to get an idea of what the site has to offer.

I'm Your Boy Toy delivers on their site theme - every episode offers up a horny twink or guy in his early twenties sucking and fucking (or getting fucked by) a man in his thirties or forties. The sex is hot as are the performers, many of whom are well-known porn stars. There are 88 videos, a mix of hot sex and interviews with the guys, and each comes with a picture set. The site no longer updates, but members get access to 11 bonus sites and video collection from the same network. While I was disappointed about the lack of updates, I liked the content on offer at I'm Your Boy Toy, with horny twinks from 18 to around 25 with older men.

Things we disliked

  • Over half the videos are interviews
  • Most of the bonus sites don't update

Click here to visit I'm Your Boy Toy

ImYourBoyToy Screenshots

About Reviews

Online since 1999, GayDemon is a trusted guide to gay porn sites. On this page you can find a in-depth, detailed review of I'm Your Boy Toy with our honest opinion about this site. The review outline what you can expect to find as a member if you subscribe to I'm Your Boy Toy. The review was as accurate as possible when it was written on the 8 Jul 2021, but sites constantly change. GayDemon cannot guarantee that you will find the exact same content or features when you visit. Please contact me or leave a comment if you have any questions.

Legal stuff

GayDemon only write reviews of gay porn sites that are legal and safe to visit. This review contain our honest options, however GayDemon receive commission from a membership sale if you decide to join this site. We can only continue to write reviews with your support through your purchases. (97102)