Bait Buddies

Bait Buddies Review

Bait Buddies is one of the original “tricked straight guy” sites, and it’s been around since 2007. When I last visited the site in September 2024, it looked much as it does today, and at a quick glance not much seems to have changed. However, there do appear to have been regular updates. While newer and older episodes vary in theme, the bottom line is the same: the site tricks straight amateurs who think they’re about to do straight porn into having gay sex. The men range through their twenties and thirties, with a few a little older, and they’re generally in good shape, with plenty of well-built jocks and hunks. They’re mostly White, but there’s also a good number of Black and Latin guys, along with a mix of smooth and hairy men, bearded or clean-shaven, tattooed or not. Dick sizes, heights, and hair color are all over the map.

Older videos often feature a gay guy posing as straight, along with a woman who acts as bait to make the “straight” guys more comfortable stripping and getting aroused. While interviewing both men at the same time, she suggests she might do a scene with them. In one scene I watched, she asked if they had ever considered being with another guy. Before long, the “straight” guy is standing there while the other guy is on his knees, being guided by her on what to do. After a few minutes, the situation shifts when the other guy storms off, leaving the “straight” guy to finish things on his own while focused on the woman.

The newer episodes follows a theme where a straight and a gay guy are called in for an audition, but the straight guy is lured by the idea of doing a straight porn shoot with a woman and thinks the other dude is straight, too. Sometimes the gay performer is a familiar face like Joel Someone, Gio Carrera, or Scott DeMarco. Eventually the producer lets the guys know that the woman they were going to fuck didn't show up (sometimes he tells the guys that they have to prove they can get hard before he brings her out). In order to save the audition, he's willing to double their fee if they'll play with each other. The straight guy kicks up a fuss (some are better at it than others), but eventually these two dudes get down to business. 

And of course, we all know where this goes. The director uses any number of devices and excuses to get the straight guy to go further and have sex with the other guy. The director might suggest they trade handjobs or he might tell the straight guy he can earn more money if he let's the other guy blow him. Invariably the straight guy fucks the gay dude, or sometimes it's the other way around. Once in a while, a new video features two recurring regulars or a recurring regular with a gay porn star, but those don't happen as often.

The older Bait Buddies scenarios seem pretty authentic, and the straight guys often throw a fit or protest when they're faced with having sex with another guy. But these days the site uses mostly porn performers and even gay porn regulars who play the roles of straight guys. For instance, one of the latest videos features Brogan Reed, who has filmed dozens of gay sex videos, but when the producer asks him why he wanted to try porn he said, "Because I like sex and I like to try new things." Many of the guys return, and those straight guys suddenly become bait for other straight guys. Occasionally, the site puts up a jack-off solo, but the most recent one was in Sept and Nov 2025.

Bait Buddies now offers 938 exclusive videos in MP4 format, up from 885 when I last visited. Videos are available for both streaming and download, but only in a single resolution: newer scenes are sized at 1280x720 (HD), while the oldest videos are available at 640x480 (SD). Quality is generally good overall, with newer content looking sharper than the older material. Videos run around 25 to 30 minutes on average. Streaming is mobile compatible, though limited to a single resolution, and while newer videos hold up reasonably well in full screen, the older ones are noticeably less crisp.

Each video comes with a picture set. These pics are good amateur quality digital stills; in the online galleries, the pictures usually display at 533x800, but if you download the zip files you'll get bigger pics ranging from 365x550 (oldest) to 1500x1000 (newest). There may be other sizes, too. If you prefer, you can also save the pictures individually by right-clicking any thumb and the "saving as" link; I was unable to save the larger images by right clicking. There's no slideshow offered but there are forward and back controls on the image viewer to ease navigation.

Since my last visit in September 2024, the site has grown from 885 to 938 videos, with 53 new scenes added over roughly 18 months. That works out to an average of about three new videos per month. While that falls a little short of a strict once-a-week schedule, it still points to a steady and fairly consistent update pattern overall.

When it comes to issues, BaitBuddies has a few things worth mentioning. Full members can download up to 20 hours of videos per week, and after that your downloads will be blocked for between 12 and 72 hours, although you'll still be able to stream the videos. Also, the site prohibits the use of automatic downloading software. Trial members can stream videos only; downloads require full members. Other than that, there's not a lot to complain about; BaitBuddies is easy to navigate, updates regularly, and there's a model index with profiles and links to all their scenes. 

Bait Buddies remains one of the more consistent "tricked straight guy" sites around, with a strong mix of models across 938 exclusive videos that can be downloaded, streamed, and watched on your mobiles. Each episode also comes with a set of pics, and the site has clearly continued to update regularly since my last visit. The setup is familiar: guys turn up expecting to film with a woman and end up crossing the line into something else. Even if the newer scenes lean more into fantasy, they’re still easy to watch and the sex is hot.

Visit Bait Buddies Now