Amateur Straight Guys

10 Sep 2020 Score 70 / 100 Mobile friendly

  • Videos 4 stars
  • Pictures 4 stars
  • Unique 4 stars
  • Size 4 stars
Review score 70
  • 4 stars Cost
  • 0 stars Updates
  • 4 stars Usability
  • 4 stars Claims

Amateur Straight Guys offers horny straight guys, and some who are bi-curious or gay, many in their first-time gay sex experiences. Hot college-age guys with slim, athletic, or muscled bodies jacking their cocks, sucking dick and taking it up the ass. Mostly duos, but quite a few threeways and solos. 622 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles.

Click here to visit Amateur Straight Guys

Since Last Review

  • Site has added 95 videos
  • Full access trial added
  • Prices have changed
  • Site no longer adds new content

Video info

Videos offered for download and streaming

622 exclusive videos in MP4 format. Most sized at 640x480 plus 1 smaller size at amateur to good amateur quality, some available in larger sizes, oldest available only at 640x480. Streaming and mobile compatible videos available. No DRM used.

Picture info

91 picture sets in model galleries. Pics are digital stills, sizes vary from 333x500 to 390x600 at good amateur quality. Zip files available, no slideshows offered. Pics can be saved individually. 3 to 100+ pictures per set.

Bonus content

9 videos from Dirty Bird Pictures DVDs.

Site issues

yThis site no longer updates!

Site is recycling updates.

Membership Cost

  • Trial: $2.95 (recurring at $16.95 every 30 days)
  • Monthly: $24.95 (30 days, non-recurring)
  • Quarterly: $44.95 (recurring every 90 days)
  • Yearly: $99.95 (365 days, non-recurring)


Amateur Straight Guys Review

Amateur Straight Guys was one of the original straight guy sites that emerged on the web in 2000. It featured guys getting serviced by the site's producers or getting it on with another guy, and the site was hugely popular. If you love watching real straight guys trying sex with another guy - or coming back to try it again - join me as we take a fresh look at this site and see what's new.

The guys here are all over the map, but essentially they're straight guys who were supposedly inexperienced when it came to guy-on-guy sex, although there are some bisexual, bi-curious, and gay guys in the mix. The performers are generally in their twenties, and while you may recognize the odd one who went on to do more porn filming, the men here are mostly amateurs. Some are slender, others have more athletic bodies, and still others obviously work out quite a bit. And you'll find a mix of smooth or hairy, tattoos, those who are clean shaven and others with face scruff - they're all here. I found quite a few of the guys to be good looking or handsome, and surfers obviously did, too, because the site was hugely popular for years.

Let's talk about what's happening in the recent scenes. The newest is called "Live: Barrett, Cameron & Jason," and features three attractive "regular guy" types – Barrett Long, Cameron Taylor and Jason Crew – and the scene was originally streamed live. Cameron sucks first one, then both of these huge, meaty cocks, then Barrett plunges his 11 inches of uncut meat deep into Cameron's tight hole, and Cameron looks like he's having some trouble. He gets boned further by Jason's 10 incher before both guys unload on Cameron's face and chest, and he sucks one of the guy's dicks clean. In "Vault: Ben & Tom Blowjobs," two first-time amateur guys are watching straight porn, and they're finally horny enough to jerk off together, stroke each other's dicks, and finally suck each other's cocks.

The early videos at Amateur Straight Guys feature guys getting stroked or sucked off by the site's two producers, Doug and Jay, who together appear a number of videos, although Doug isn't listed in the model index. The remaining videos feature guys in solos or playing with each other and exploring guy-on-guy sex without the help of the producers. And this is the direction the newer ASG took much of the time. In a blog post Dink says: "My vision for the new ASG is a celebration of sex between men in general with our focus to remain slanted toward sex between the more masculine and straight-identifying of men." And that's a lot of what we find here.

Amateur Straight Guys offers 622 exclusive videos in MP4 format. Many of the latest updates are sized at 640x480 and one smaller size at average to good amateur quality, depending on when the videos were produced; I found a few sized at 1280x720 as well, and all the newer videos are also available in HLS format (those downloads end in .m3u8, and I wasn't able to play them, but that's okay since I had no problem playing the MP4s). Some of the newest productions are also offered at 1280x720, a few at full HD at 1920x1080, but these aren't the latest updates - more about that later. Some of the oldest videos are only available in one size at 640x360 at amateur quality, but that's small enough to play on pretty much any mobile. All the videos can be streamed, and quality depends on the quality of the original video. I wouldn't suggest going full screen with most of these.

The site has has 390 models, and 91 of them have galleries. These galleries have anywhere from a few to over 100 digital stills that come in a variety of sizes but are smallish from 333x500 to 358x550, but no bigger than 390x600. You can save the pics individually or download entire sets in zip files. You can also view the photos online in thumbnail galleries, but there are no hands-free slideshows nor are there any forward or back controls.

Amateur Straight Guys members also get access to nine bonus videos where you'll find some scenes including military and gym sex from Dirty Bird Pictures DVDs. There are a few familiar faces including Brent Corrigan, Corbett Harper, and Devin Moss. The videos are available to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles.

Now let's talk about updates. Amateur Straight Guys has 95 more videos than there were two years ago, but there's more to it than that. From around 2007 to around 2017, the site stopped producing new content; they shot some new videos for a while, but not that many are on the site. All the recent updates are older videos that were removed and remastered, which is why most of the new videos are only 640x480, but bigger than they were first shown on the site. However, the site is now recycling, and if you've been a member before, you can expect to see familiar videos in the updates.

Are there other issues? Well, the updates aren't dated, so you won't know when or how often the site updates. In the older productions, Doug and Jay did a lot of commentary and interaction with the guys, so you'll hear an "Oh, wow!" when a guy shoots his load, or sometimes they jump in and give direction. Whether you like it or find it irritating depends on your preferences. And, as already mentioned, most of the videos are on the small side, some at only amateur quality.

Amateur Straight Guys offers horny straight, bisexual, bi-curious, and gay guys in a variety of scenes from solos to threesomes, and while many of the guys are straight when they do their first shoot, some come back more than once for the cash or the sex, or both. There are 622 exclusive videos to download, stream, and watch on your mobiles, and while they had started updating again on our last visit, all the recent updates are recycled older scenes. Still, the action is hot from one of the first gay-for-pay and first-timer sites, and if you love amateur guys these videos may hit the spot. And if you remember some of the scenes from the site's glory days, you may want to revisit them again.

Things we liked

  • Exclusive content
  • Hot straight guys in hotter scenarios
  • Real first-timers and some repeats
  • Videos are downloadable (no DRM used)
  • Can do 4 simultaneous downloads
  • Site and videos are mobile compatible

Things we disliked

  • Most vids are small and average quality
  • Updates aren't dated
  • Only 91 of 390 models have pic sets

Click here to visit Amateur Straight Guys

AmateurStraightGuys Screenshots

About Reviews

Online since 1999, GayDemon is a trusted guide to gay porn sites. On this page you can find a in-depth, detailed review of Amateur Straight Guys ( with our honest opinion about this site. The review outline what you can expect to find as a member if you subscribe to AmateurStraightGuys. The review was as accurate as possible when it was written on the 10 Sep 2020, but sites constantly change. GayDemon cannot guarantee that you will find the exact same content or features when you visit. Please contact me or leave a comment if you have any questions.

Legal stuff

GayDemon only write reviews of gay porn sites that are legal and safe to visit. This review contain our honest options, however GayDemon receive commission from a membership sale if you decide to join this site. We can only continue to write reviews with your support through your purchases. (96696)