The Ugly Duckling

Chapter 8

I woke up the next morning, I replayed the events from the previous night in my head. Pleased that we got Travis to step outside his comfort zone, but when did Kyle figure out who I was? It didn’t really matter at this point, I felt like I had accomplished my mission.

I got out of bed and dressed, I was meeting Andy and Jenna for breakfast. They were already at the restaurant when I walked in.

I sat down and said, “hey guys, you been waiting long?”

Jenna smiled, “no, we just got here.”

Andy asked, “so, how did things go last night?”

I looked to Jenna and then to him, he saw me and said, “I’m sorry, I told her what is going on, we don’t have any secrets, I hope you don’t mind.”

I shook my head, “no, not at all. Just stop me if I give you too much information.”

They laughed, “ok, spill it.”

I said, “well, before Kyle came over, he messaged me and asked if he could bring a friend along.”

Andy said, “ok, wow, I was just getting used to Kyle messing around with guys, now you tell me he has a regular fuck buddy.”

I nodded, “oh, it gets better. His buddy is Travis.”

Andy stuttered, “but Travis is married.”

I shrugged, “I guess he’s not a fanatic about it. Anyway, Kyle was more into it than Travis, we had to encourage him a little bit.”

Andy just stared, “wow, so now what are you going to do?”

I said, “I don’t know if I’m going to do anything. I mean, I kind of feel like I got my revenge.”

Jenna asked, “what are you going to say to them at the reunion tomorrow night?"

I paused, “oh shit, I hadn’t thought about that.”

Andy laughed, “please don’t show up before we do, I want to see the look on their faces when they realize who you are.”

I said, “well, I think Kyle knows, he winked at me and said he would see me at the reunion.”

Andy asked, “do you think he’ll tell the others?”

I shrugged, “I’m not sure, I guess it doesn’t matter, like you said the look on their face tomorrow night will be worth it.”

We spent the rest of the day together and that night, Andy’s mom and dad invited us over for dinner at their house.

The next day, Andy, his dad, brother, and I shot a round of golf. That afternoon I went back to my room to get ready for the reunion. I got dressed and was looking at myself in the mirror, I had bought new clothes for the occasion and decided to wear my hair down. I usually wore it in a ponytail, but I thought that putting it down was a little sexier, giving me a bit of a bad boy look. I made my final adjustments and thought I looked pretty good, looking forward to strutting in that room and seeing the reactions of all my old classmates.

I pulled up to the banquet hall and walked toward the door, just as Andy and Jenna were arriving, they looked damn good too. They really did make a cute couple and they looked like they were still in love. Holly Jacobs was manning the table at the entrance, welcoming everyone to the reunion. She was the one in our class that always had to be in on the planning of everything in high school, the prom, homecoming, and every dance we had.

She smiled at Andy and Jenna and said, “Andy Shaw, right?”

He smiled back, “yes Holly, and this is my wife, Jenna.”

Holly searched her table and handed Andy a name tag, she beamed as she said, “I thought it would be so cute to make name tags with everybody’s senior picture on it, see, aren’t they cute?”

Andy rolled his eyes, “sure, cute.”

I chuckled as Holly made a spouse name tag for Jenna. Holly then turned to me and grinned, “don’t tell me, I’ll get it… Chad Harper.” I shook my head, she scanned her tags, I saw she had them in alphabetical order “oh wait, it’s Bobby Williams.”

I smiled, “no, but you’re getting closer, the next one down.”

She looked at the tags, then back to me, “Tyler Wilton?”

I nodded, “nice to see you again Holly.”

She stuttered, “you too Tyler, wow, you have changed.”

I smiled, “thank you,” I took my name tag, I didn’t put it on just yet, we walked into the room, over half the class was already there.

We walked over to the bar, and each got a drink and turned to scan the crowd. We chatted with a few classmates that were nearby and then I nudged Andy. He looked across the room, there sat the “jock squad”, Travis, Reggie and Matt with their wives, and Kyle was solo.

Andy asked, “are you going to go say hi?”

I took a big drink of my beer, “yes, I think I will.”

Andy and Jenna walked in front of me, they made it to the table and Andy said, “hi guys, this is my wife Jenna,”

They all returned the greeting and introduced their wives as I walked up next to Andy. Everyone at the table, except Kyle, suddenly looked worried.

Reggie spoke first, “TJ, what are you doing here?” The other three just looked at Reggie, not sure what to say.

Reggie turned to his wife, “This is TJ, the one I told you about that is working on our heat gun project.”

She nodded and smiled. All eyes were on me as they waited for me to say something.

I saw more panic in their eyes as I said, “it’s nice to see all of you again, hard to believe it has been ten years, huh?”

They all seemed a little bit relieved, then Matt asked, “were you in our class?”

I smiled, “sure I was, oh wait, I know why you don’t recognize me, I grew my hair out a little, and I used to go by Tyler. I guess I should put my name tag on.” I put the tag on my chest as they all turned pale again, except of course Kyle, he just had a grin on his face.

I said, “well, it was nice to see all of you again, I think Andy and I will go mingle a bit.”

We turned and walked away, once we were out of ear shot, Andy turned to me, “did you see the fear in their eyes?”

I chuckled, “yeah, that was very satisfying, I wonder if any of them will talk to me again.”

We talked to more of our classmates, then found a table to sit at before they served the meal. After we had eaten, I went to the bar to get us another round of drinks. Just as the bartender handed me the drinks, Kyle walked up to order a round for his table.

He smiled, “so you got us all back pretty good, didn’t you, Tyler?”

I shrugged, “what do you mean?”

He chuckled, “when the wives went to the bathroom, Matt and Reggie told us what happened, and Travis told them about us. They couldn’t believe they didn’t figure out who you were.”

I asked, “so, when did you figure it out?”

He said, “I thought you looked familiar when you answered the door Thursday night, but I couldn’t place you until you were sucking my dick and looked up at me, I flashed back to high school, and I remembered where I saw those eyes.”

I laughed, “that’s why you smiled like that.”

He nodded, “so, what are you going to do now?”

I took a big drink of my beer, “well, I don’t want to break up anyone’s marriage, so I won’t say anything tonight, but I have a question for you, if I can get the others to my hotel room tomorrow, will join us?”

He smirked, “sure, that could be fun.”

I said, “good, I was just thinking, I didn’t get a chance to fuck you.”

Kyle said, “yeah, I’ll be sure to not let that happen this time.”

I smiled, “Kyle McCain, are you coming out to me?”

He took a drink, “yeah, I guess I am, I think it’s time I quit living a lie.”

I said, “be at my room at 2, tomorrow afternoon.” We clinked our drinks, and we went back to our tables.

I was able to talk to the other three throughout the night, I told them if they would come to my room the next day, I would keep their secret, they all agreed, I also told them not to tell the others.

Kyle was the first to arrive, I had told the others to meet me at 2:30 so I knew we could talk first.

Kyle said, “I should start by saying that I am sorry for what I did in high school. I was just a stupid kid, and I couldn’t admit to myself or anyone that I liked guys. I guess you were an easy target.”

I said, “well to be honest, I was a little flattered that the hottest guy in school, let me suck his cock. But once I went to college and learned that you just used me, I was a little pissed. I never really planned to get even with all you guys, but when I saw Matt in the bar that night and he didn’t recognize me, I guess all the pieces sort of just fell into place.”

He chuckled, “yeah, you sure made everyone uncomfortable at the reunion, but we all deserved it.”

We heard a knock at the door, Kyle smiled at me, “let the fun begin.” I grinned and answered the door.

Kyle was on the bed around the corner as I let Reggie in. He said, “thanks for not saying anything to my wife last night.”

I said, “I’m not looking to break anyone up, just getting a little pay back for being used in high school.”

He hung his head, “yeah, I guess I should say I’m sorry about that.”

I smiled, “you can tell me when the rest get here.”

He asked, “the rest?” We walked into the room, and he saw Kyle sitting there, he looked at me as there was another knock on the door. I let Matt in, and we had a similar conversation, as we walked around the corner, Kyle and Reggie were already kissing. Matt looked at them and then at me, he shrugged then joined them on the bed. They all began to shed clothes as the final knock came. I shut the door behind Travis and pulled him down for a kiss, he kissed back without complaint this time. He looked down at me, “Kyle is right, it’s not that bad.”

I smiled, “glad to hear you are coming around, shall we join the others?”

His eyes widened, “the others?”

I took his hand and led him to the bed as he said, “oh, now I see.”

We all finished undressing and were soon piled on the bed, kissing, and running our hands all over each other’s bodies. I was a little surprised when Travis was the first to grab my dick and start to lick it, up one side and down the other. Soon, we all had a cock in our mouths, rotating every few minutes. Travis and Kyle were sucking each other, and I was sucking Reggie, he was sucking Matt and he was sucking me. We flipped so I could suck Matt and play with those huge balls, I knew Reggie was the best cock sucker in the room, so I was happy when it was his turn to please me. I started working my finger into Matt’s hole as he moaned around Reggie’s dick. I moved to join Travis and Kyle, Reggie and Matt went to work on each other. Once we had sucked each other, I started to rim Travis, again he was more receptive than the last time. I spread his cheeks apart and motioned for Kyle to fuck him, Travis was on his knees and had his head down on the bed. A perfect position to get his ass pounded, Kyle was happy to fill his hole. I stepped behind Kyle and said, “lean forward, I want your ass.” He smiled as he paused his assault on Travis’s ass. When I was balls deep in Kyle he started to thrust in and out, Travis and I just stayed still while Kyle did all the work, all five of panting like a pack of dogs. I looked over at Matt’s big nuts slapping Reggie’s ass cheeks with every push. Reggie was in the same position as Travis, they had leaned together and were kissing as their holes were being abused. I pulled out of Kyle and moved over to give Matt my cock, Matt gave me a kiss over his shoulder as I pushed in. Before long, we all moved around and now my cock was in Reggie and his was in Kyle, Travis was fucking Matt.

We were all moaning and groaning, and for a split second, I was worried about being too loud and disturbing the next room. I was sure the headboard was bouncing against the wall, but when Travis started to push his dick into me, I decided I didn’t care. We took a short break, to kiss and reposition, Matt laid down on his side, Travis laid behind him and started to fuck him, Reggie followed suit and was fucking Travis, then Kyle was fucking Reggie, and I completed the chain fucking Kyle. I’m not sure how, but before long we were all in rhythm as we fucked the guy in front of us.

Reggie groaned, “oh shit, I’m getting close.”

Kyle added, “me too.”

Travis once again surprised us all when he said, “I want you guys to all cum on me.”

Travis lay in the center of the bed, jacking his cock, Kyle and I were on one side, Reggie and Matt were on the other. Kyle and I kissed as we stroked our cocks, I felt my nuts tighten and I aimed my dick at Travis’s face and unloaded, he eagerly licked his lips clean. Reggie was next adding his white cream to Travis’s face, Matt and Kyle followed, covering Travis’s chest with their seed. Travis picked up a finger full of cum from his chest and ate the Matt and Kyle mixture. We all leaned down to get a good taste of everyone else’s sperm and then fed it to Travis with our kisses. Travis started to shake then unloaded the biggest load of all of us, the first volley landed on his own face. After another round of licking up cum and kissing we all collapsed onto the bed to catch our breath.

Kyle broke the silence, “guys. I have a confession, I’m gay.”

Matt snorted, “really, do you think?”

Reggie said, “I might be a little bi, because I want to go home and fuck the shit out of my wife right now.”

Matt and Travis agreed with Reggie, if they had to put a label on what just happened.

We took turns in the shower to clean up and decided we were all looking forward to our next reunion. I packed and after a quick stop to say goodbye to Andy and Jenna, I was on my way back home. As I drove, I thought about the eventful weekend.

They say the best revenge is a life well lived, I smiled when I decided I was living my best life, and I got my revenge.

 

---

 The End???

This is where I planned to end this story but judging by the comments from some of my regular readers, I could be convinced to continue it for a few more chapters. Please let me know in the comments and I will see if I can develop some more chapters. Thanks for reading.