How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 40

Truth and Dare

Chris grinned and said, “So, we’re all in agreement; It’s all for one and cum for all.” He didn’t know who’s pillow hit him first.

We’d just agreed on a plan to consummate our three-way relationship when Chris had come up with that corny remark. Elijah and I let him have it from both sides. By the time we were done with the pillow fight, we were all hard again, but we decided it would be best if we grabbed a shower before going to bed instead of beginning another round. We grudgingly walked into my ensuite allowing our divining rods to lead the way, we were looking for water after all, haha. Once the water temperature warmed up, we stepped in and began shampooing each other’s hair. It felt strange having two pairs of hands lathering up my hair and none of them were mine. It was a very good strange, though. I knew when I reciprocated and was shampooing Elijah’s hair how he must feel. The same went for Chris when Elijah and I were massaging the shampoo into his scalp. The shower was both intimate and invigorating. We had thoroughly soaped every inch of each other and were rinsing off when Elijah moved against me, with his stiff cock wedged between my buns and said, “Remember the first time in Josh’s parent’s house that you let me fuck you?” I looked back and said, “How could I forget. Is this where we relive that moment?” Elijah nibbled on my ear and said, “I hope so. Would you be ok with that?” I nodded and asked Chris, “As long as you’re ok with it.” Chris smiled and said, “I think it would be hot, especially if you’re sucking my cock while he fucks you.” I grinned and said, “I think I saw that one coming. Game on!” I couldn’t resist the last comment and hoped they’d get the reference. Chris turned a bit pink, and Elijah snickered behind me and said, “So Carl wasn’t the only one who overheard that.” I just grinned and then sighed as Elijah rubbed his stiff cock between my butt cheeks. Chris pressed up against me, wedging our rigid cocks together as we kissed. Elijah moved back and I felt a soapy finger invading my hole. I groaned into Chris’ mouth as his tongue played with mine. Elijah quickly added a second and then third finger as he was anxious to get inside me. I soon felt empty as he removed his fingers and I drew a deep breath in preparation for his cock to enter me. He pressed it between my buns once more for a few strokes and then I felt the head of his cock pressing against my hole. I winced a little as he entered me with just the head penetrating my tight ring. Chris knew what was happening and began kissing me harder as Elijah slowly entered me. Elijah began kissing my shoulder and neck as he edged the last couple inches inside me until I was sandwiched tightly between them with Elijah’s full length buried inside me. Elijah then began slowly taking long strokes back and forth. Chris moved back a little and pulled my neck. I smiled as I slowly bent forward and took his cock in my mouth. I licked around the head of his cock and then pulled off of it to lick his balls as Elijah continued his slow fuck. I looked up at Chris as I slowly licked the underside of his stiff rod from base to tip before taking it back into my mouth. I began sucking him in rhythm to the fucking I was receiving from Elijah. Soon Chris was rocking his hips back and forth, fucking my mouth while Elijah fucked my ass. Elijah began fucking me faster and the shower was filled with slapping sounds as he slammed into my firm, wet buns. Chris matched Elijah’s pace and was shoving the full length of his cock into my mouth as my nose smashed into his pubic bush. Chris said, “This is so fire! Fuck his ass, Elijah!” Elijah replied, “Fuck yeah! Take our cocks, Jeremy! Fuck his mouth, Chris!” All I could do was moan on Chris’ cock and enjoy the fucking I was receiving. My own cock was throbbing as it bobbed between my thighs. Elijah’s thrusts were getting more forceful and more ragged as he cried out, “Fuck! I’m getting close! Fuck yeah! Fuck! Fuck! I’m cumming!” I felt his cock swell inside me and then pulse as he flooded my guts with his baby makers. Then Chris said, “I’m getting close too.” My own nuts were getting ready to explode as well but all I could do was moan louder on Chris’ cock as Elijah finished cumming while pressing tightly inside me. Chris placed his hands on either side of my head and said, “I’m gonna cum!” I felt Chris’ cock swell in my mouth before wad after wad of his cum began flooding it. I moaned loudly as my own cock exploded and sent my seed flying down onto the shower floor. Some though splattered across Chris’ legs and feet. I kept swallowing Chris’ sweet and salty cream as it seemed as if he would never stop. He was now holding my shoulders for support and Elijah was holding my hips. I was wondering who was supporting me as my knees were weak from the experience. As Chris’ cock finally stopped pumping his cum into my mouth, I pulled my mouth off it and slowly straightened up. I leaned back into Elijah’s chest. Elijah leaned back against the shower wall with his cock still inside me. I turned my head and we kissed. Chris then moved in, sandwiching me once more between them as the three of us kissed. Eventually, we separated and once again lathered each other up and rinsed off just as the water started getting cold. We stepped out and dried each other off. All three of us had huge smiles on our faces as we made our way back into my bedroom. We climbed into bed in our usual positions, with Chris to my right and Elijah on my left side. We kissed a bit more and then Chris and Elijah gave each other a final kiss before linking their fingers and laying their heads on my chest. I wrapped an arm over each of their shoulders and drifted off to sleep.

I thought I was having a dream as I felt a wet warmth surrounding my cock but as I opened my eyes, I was pleasantly surprised to see Elijah’s mouth bobbing up and down on my stiff rod. Chris was half on and half off the bed beneath Elijah with his mouth full of Elijah’s cock. I smiled and said, “What a hot sight to be awakened to.” Elijah glanced up at me with a twinkle in his eyes and then resumed sucking my cock while he moaned. I then realized why he was moaning as I noticed that Chris had a couple fingers working away in Elijah’s ass. Chris pulled his mouth off Elijah’s cock and asked, “You finally awake Jeremy?” I said, “Either that or I’m having a hell of a great dream.” Chris then said, “Are you ready to fuck this ass I’m prepping for you?” I grinned and said, “For me? Sure!” Elijah then crawled out from under Elijah and Elijah pulled his mouth off my cock and said, “Fuck my ass, Jeremy. I want it hard.” I climbed off the bed and moved behind Elijah who remained on all fours at the end of the bed, “I’ll try to give you what you want.” Chris then climbed back under Elijah but in a sixty-nine position this time. Before taking Elijah’s cock back into his mouth, he said, “Tear that ass up, Jeremy.” I rubbed the head of my cock up and down the deep valley between Elijah’s firm buns, then I asked him, “Are you ready for my cock?” All I heard was an, “Ummmhmmm.” Elijah already had a mouth full of Chris’ cock. I pressed until the head of my cock popped inside him. I heard him yelp, “MMMm!”. I waited for a few moments to let him get used to me. I didn’t need to wait long. Elijah began pushing back onto my cock, trying to get me inside him. He got his wish as I slowly penetrated him until I was pressed tightly against those firm buns. I began a slow fuck at first, speeding up with each stroke until I had a rhythm going and was making slapping sounds as I slammed into his firm buns. Elijah was moaning in pleasure beneath me, and Chris was slurping on Elijah’s cock beneath him. I knew I wouldn’t last too much longer, so I decided to give Elijah what he wanted and began jackhammering into him. Elijah arched his back a little more and pushed back a little, taking my cock like a champ. His moans became one continuous higher pitched drone on Chris’ cock. Suddenly, I felt his anus clamping down on my cock in spasms and I realized he was cumming, pumping his seed down Chris’ throat. That brought me over the edge as well and I slammed into Elijah hard and began pumping my own seed deep inside him. As my cock slowly finished pumping, I laid across Elijah’s back, catching my breath. I kissed Elijah’s neck and then slowly drew upright and pulled my still hard shaft from Elijah. As soon as my cock was out of his hole, Elijah said, “That was just what I needed. Thanks Jeremy.” Elijah then rolled around onto his back next to Chris. They both had cum running down the corners of their mouths. I leaned down and kissed Chris whose head was at my legs and then crawled on top of Elijah and kissed him. Chris swung around and kissed Elijah and said, “Well, Elijah has fucked both of us and you fucked him. We’re making pretty good headway in consummating this throuple thing and I think I’m glad we agreed to this.” “Me too”, Elijah and I said in unison. We showered together and then went into the kitchen to make breakfast. As we were eating, Carl called, “Hey! Hope you had a good night. Chuck and I sure did.” I replied, “We had an awesome time.” Carl then said, “I’m, um glad you don’t seem so stressed out over that decision you were trying not to have to make.” I knew by how cryptic he was being that Chuck must be nearby. I covered the phone for a moment and asked Elijah and Chris, “Is it ok if I let Carl know about out arrangement?” Elijah shrugged and Chris said, “As long as he doesn’t tell Chuck.” I replied, "He won’t unless you’re ok with it but you already have Chuck suspicious.” I heard Carl ask, “You still there, Jeremy?” I said to Carl, “Yeah, I just had to ask Elijah and Chris something.” Carl said, “Yeah, I know they have a competition going for you. They tried to play it off, but I knew what they meant by the ‘game on’ comment. Don’t tell them I know though. Chuck left the room for the moment so I can talk more freely.” I grinned and said, “I don’t think that’s a thing anymore, at least for now the competition is over.” Carl said in a surprised but toned-down voice, “You mean one of them backed off?” I laughed and said, “Hell no! I’ll fill you in later.” Carl then said, “Anyway, could you pick us up so Chuck can get his car? We still need to go over to the Reynolds also.” I said, “Sure. Let me finish eating. I’ll be over after that.” I filled Chris and Elijah in on having to go get Carl and Chuck. Chris and Elijah looked to each other and then back to me sheepishly. I knew they were up to something and asked, “What’s up?” Chris said, “Well, Elijah has to leave today to return to his campus and though we each had oral, I haven’t had the chance to breed him yet.” I grinned and said, “If you’re asking if I mind if you two fuck while I’m gone, have fun. Just make sure you’re not still going at it when we return. I know this consummation thing is important to you. As far as I’m concerned, what’s important is that I love you both.” They both got up and kissed me and each said, “I love you too.” We cleaned up the dishes and I headed out to Chuck’s place.

I arrived at Chuck’s apartment, and he let me in and immediately gave me a tour of the place. It was small but plenty large enough for one or two people as long as they were sharing the single bedroom. He offered me a cup of coffee and I accepted, not because I wanted another cup of caffeine, but because I figured it would give Chris and Elijah a little more time. As we sat in the kitchen drinking coffee, Chuck asked me, “So, what did you guys do last night after we left.” I knew he was fishing, so I was vague, “We sat around the fire, drinking and talking until the fire was dying, then we went inside, drank some more and went to bed.” Chuck then asked, “So Chris stayed over?” I gave a one-word answer, “Yeah.” Carl then quickly said, “Good, then maybe he can join us at the Reynolds so we can get their yardwork done faster.” I said, “I’m sure he’ll be more than willing to help.” Then I asked Chuck, “Are you coming along, Chuck?” Chuck said, “Of course I will. They’re really nice people.” I then asked Chuck, “So, you’re going to be working next Saturday?” I was trying to keep him from returning to fishing but he managed to return, “Yeah, I hate these weekend shifts, but it pays the bills. So, Elijah will be heading back to his campus tonight and you guys weren’t able to have any fun with Chris staying. That must have sucked.” I smiled and said, “We still had fun. Having sex isn’t the only way of having fun.” Carl was looking a little anxious and said, “We should get going. We do have to get to the Reynolds’ place.” I replied, “You’re right. We should get going.” On the way over to the house, Chuck took one more shot at fishing, “So, does Chris know you guys mess around?” Carl said, “Chuck! What’s with all these questions about Chris?” Chuck said, “I’m just curious why a straight boy would be hanging around with us.”

After I had left, Chris and Elijah sat at the kitchen table. They were a little nervous. Even though they had had sex several times already, this would be the first time that it would be just the two of them. Elijah smiled over at Chris and Chris gave him a sheepish smile back. Elijah finally said, “Hey, I don’t want this to be uncomfortable and I don’t want you to feel obligated to do this, Chris.” Chris replied, “I’m sorry. It’s just that Jeremy was always here before. I’m not feeling obligated, but I am a little nervous. I mean up until yesterday, the only person I’ve been intimate with is Jeremy. The other times, when we all were having sex, it wasn’t intimate to me. It was just having fun. Yesterday, last night, was different. It felt intimate with you, but Jeremy was here also.” Elijah asked, “So it wouldn’t feel intimate without Jeremy here.” Chris looked to Elijah with his eyes wide and said, “No! I’m not saying that, Elijah. I like you and want us to have some intimacy. I wouldn’t have agreed to this throuple thing if I didn’t like you. I’m just a little nervous.” Elijah got up and stepped behind Chris. He bent down and kissed Chris’ neck and then moved to his chin. Chris tilted his head back and allowed himself to enjoy it. Then Elijah straightened back up and held out his hand to Chris. Chris took Elijah’s hand and followed him into the living room in front of the sofa. Elijah then pulled Chris’ T-shirt up over his head and dropped it to the floor. Elijah then moved in and they kissed for a bit before Chris pulled back. Elijah looked at his questioningly, but Chris gave him a smile and gripped the bottom of Elijah’s T-shirt and pulled it over his head before dropping it to the floor. This time, Chris moved in and resumed their kiss. Elijah brought his left hand to Chris’ upper back and his right hand cupped Chris’ firm left butt cheek and pulled him in tighter. They both moaned in each other’s mouths as they each felt the other’s hardness through their shorts. They broke their kiss in laughter as they had simultaneously reached to push the other’s shorts down. Elijah was caught by surprise as Chris dropped to his knees and took his stiff rod in his left hand and began licking it, “Fuck yeah, Chris. That feels good.” Chris smiled up at him and then took Elijah’s cock into his mouth. After several minutes, Elijah reached down and pulled Chris up off his knees and asked him, “Still nervous?” Chris grinned and shook his head no. Elijah the guided Chris to sit on the sofa and said, “My turn.” Elijah dropped to his knees and took Chris’ cock into his mouth and began working his tongue around it while his mouth moved up and down the shaft while playing with his balls. Elijah was going to town on Chris’ cock and Chris had to stop him before he was too close, “Elijah! Slow down.” Chris pulled Elijah’s head up off his cock and then smiled. Chris took his cock and held it upright and asked Elijah with a smile, “Want to take a seat on this?” Elijah grinned and said, “Fuck yeah!” Elijah practically ran into Jeremy’s bedroom and returned with a bottle of lube. After lubing up Chris’ cock and his own hole, Elijah climbed across Chris’ legs, facing him and slowly impaled himself on Chris’ cock while looking into his eyes. Chris smiled back at him and said, “Fuck yeah, Elijah. You’re so tight.” Soon, Elijah’s firm buns were resting on Chris’ lap as he had a look of euphoria on his face. Chris leaned forward and gave him a quick kiss, grinned and said, “Let’s ride, cowboy.” Elijah laughed and then began moving up and down on Chris’ steely shaft. Elijah smiled at Chris as he moved up and down. They kissed passionately and then resumed smiling at each other. Aftar a while, Chris caught Elijah by surprise when he grabbed him and turned him onto his back while still inside him. Elijah looked up at him with a surprised look as Chris smiled down at him and then began to slowly fuck him. Elijah’s surprised look turned into a euphoric smile before Chris bent down and they kissed. Elijah softly moaned in Chris’ mouth as Chris rhythmically pistoned in and out of him, making love to him. They were making love for a while when Elijah broke their kiss and said, “I’m getting close.” Chris grinned and said, “Me too.” Chris then sped up slightly and moments later, Elijah’s cock unleashed rope after rope of cum between them followed by Chris saying, “Fuck yeah, Elijah! I’m cumming too!” As he grunted while cumming, Elijah gasped out, “Fuck yes! Breed me, Chris! Give me your seed!” Chris then collapsed onto Elijah as they caught their breath. Elijah drew his arms around Chris and hugged him, and said, “That was fucking lit, Chris. Thanks.” Chris said, “Yeah it was. Thanks, Elijah. I think this throuple thing is really going to work out. I just wish you weren’t fifty miles away most of the time.” Suddenly, they heard a car pulling into the driveway and Chris sat up, “Fuck! We lost track of the time!” Elijah sat up as well and said, “Quick! Grab your clothes!” They grabbed their clothes and headed for Jeremy’s bedroom and then Chris stopped and said, “Wait! I’ll use the other bathroom!”, before turning and going into the main bathroom.

I pulled into the driveway and shut off the car. I hoped Elijah and Chris had time to do the consummating, but I hurried to make sure I was the first one in the door. Carl apparently sensed my tension and said, “We’ll be right in.” I hurried into the house and called, “Chris! Elijah! We’re back!” Elijah emerged from my bedroom looking a little disheveled. I asked, “Where’s Chris?” Just then, Carl and Chuck entered the house. Elijah said, “Hey, guys!”, then asked, “So, did you break in Chuck’s apartment?” Chuck said, “We had already done that.” Carl said, “Yeah, but last night was the first time since we’re a couple.” Chuck said, “True”, and they kissed. Then Carl asked, “Where’s Chris?” The bathroom toilet flushed and then the door opened. Chris emerged and said, “Here.” He looked a little nervous and his eyes darted toward the sofa. Carl grabbed two bottles of water and handed one to Chuck and the Chuck walked to the sofa. He suddenly stopped and seemed to look at something on the floor before sitting on the sofa with a smirk on his face. Carl took a seat beside him and said, “How soon are we heading over to the Reynolds?” I said, “As soon as everyone is ready.” Elijah said, “I’m ready”. I looked at Chris who looked panicked, “Are you ready to go, Chris?” I was concerned by the look on his face, but didn’t want to ask him in front of everyone. Chris said, “Yeah, but could I borrow a different T-shirt. I don’t want to get grass stains on this one.” I said, “Sure. Let’s see what I can find.” Chris said, “Thanks.”, and followed me into my bedroom. As soon as we got into my bedroom, I asked Chris, “What’s going on? You look like you’ve just seen a ghost and you’re acting strangely.” Chris replied, “Jeremy, I don’t really need a T-shirt. We just finished having sex on the sofa and we heard you drive up. We grabbed our clothes and ran to separate bathrooms, but I missed my underwear. I think they might be under the sofa. Can I borrow a pair? It might be pretty obvious in these shorts if I go commando to the Reynolds.” I laughed at the thought of Mrs. Reynolds grabbing Chris’ butt through the thin fabric of those shorts, “I don’t know. Mrs. Reynolds would really enjoy the show. I’m sure.” Chris turned bright red and then said, “Thanks, Jeremy.”, as I threw him a pair of briefs. As he dropped his shorts and pulled the briefs on, I grabbed him a T-shirt and said, “Here, since this was your original reason for coming in here.” He pulled his shorts back on and then changed T-shirts before we returned to the living room. We all began heading out to Carl’s car before I made an excuse that I had to check on something in the house. I went back inside and walked over to the sofa. I rolled my eyes as I found Chris’ briefs next to the sofa and the bottle of lube from my bedroom. I hoped Chuck hadn’t seen them. I picked them up and took them to my bedroom. Then went out to get in Carl’s car. As I passed by Chuck in the passenger’s seat, he turned and gave me a knowing grin. Shit!

We arrived at the Reynolds and immediately went to work. Carl mowed and Chuck was edging while Chris and Elijah were weeding the garden. I concentrated on making minor repairs that were needed, some of which were requested by Mr. Reynolds. As if on cue, Mrs. Reynolds came out with a tray of lemonade, but only three glasses. Elijah smiled as he walked over to receive them, knowing he was going to get his butt pinched. Mrs. Reynolds said, “I’m sorry, but I can only carry three or four glasses at a time and since you brought so many, I have to go get the rest.” Elijah said, “No problem, Mrs. Reynolds. We appreciate the refreshments.” The he took the three glasses and turned, only to have his butt pinched with a sweet laugh behind him. He jumped a little but grinned as he stepped away. He gave me and Carl the two glasses leaving either Chris or Chuck to get the other two. I was a little concerned that it would result in an interaction between the two but figured that Elijah didn’t want Chuck to see him catering to Chris. Mrs. Reynolds emerged with the other two glasses of lemonade. Chuck noticed and set the edger down and walked over to retrieve them. He accepted the glasses and said, “You are too kind, Mrs. Reynolds.” She replied with, “It’s you boys who are so kind helping us elderly folks with work we can’t do any longer. Carl and Jeremy have such wonderful friends.” Chuck replied, “We’re happy to help, Mrs. Reynolds.” As he turned, he winced and grinned after Mrs. Reynolds groped his butt cheek. He walked over to Chris and handed him a glass and said, “Here you go maybe not so straight boy.” Chris went white as he accepted the glass and said, “Thanks.” Chuck just said, “You’re welcome.” As he smiled and gave him a wink. He then returned to edging the walkways. As we finished, Chuck walked up and handed his empty glass to Chris. Amused, Carl did the same knowing whoever returned the glasses would get molested by Mrs. Reynolds. Elijah then gave Chris his empty glass with a knowing grin. Chris realized his predicament and smiled sheepishly as he collected my glass and went up to the back door and knocked. Mr. Reynolds came out first and squeezed Chris’ shoulder before approaching Carl and me. “You boys have been so good to us. I’m glad we decided to rent the house to you, and you are welcome to rent it as long as you need. I’m so grateful for everything you and your friends do for us. You are fine, upstanding men and I’m privileged to have met you.” I smiled and said, “We’re more than happy to help you Mr. Reynolds. You’ve given us your trust and we want to show you we take that trust to heart.” Mr. Reynolds smiled and said, “I also want to thank you again for putting up with the missus little extravagance.” I laughed and said, "We’ve always viewed it as a joy we can give to Mrs. Reynolds.” He said, “Yep, and she’s always happier after your visits. Thank you.” Mrs. Reynolds then emerged with her tray and collected the glasses, then set them on the table next to her. Then she turned to Chris and said, “Thank you so much for collecting the empty glasses from you hardworking boys.” Mr. Reynolds passed by him on his way back in and squeezed his shoulder again and gave him a smile and a nod. Chris smiled back appreciatively. Then Mrs. Reynolds gave Chris a big hug and then lowered her hands down to his butt and gave both cheeks a squeeze. Chris turned bright red as he turned back to our grinning faces. As Chris was passing by Chuck, Chuck gave him another wink and said, “Way to take one for the team, Chris.” Chris was already bright red and just grinned. We had finished up and were putting the mower and tools away when Chuck pulled Chris aside and said to him, “Hey, Chris. I hope I haven’t been pissing you off by busting on you. I was pressing things because I was trying to figure out why some straight boy would want to hang out with a group of guys who are having gay sex with each other and then there was that vague remark you gave me the other day. I like you and want to be your friend. So, are we cool?” Chris nodded and smiled, “Yeah, we’re good, Chuck.” Chuck pulled him into a bro hug and Chris returned it.

The ride back was uneventful other than some ass busting about Mrs. Reynolds’ penchant for grabbing their butts. As we got into the house, they all grabbed water and went into the living room. I sat on the sofa and Elijah and Chris sat down on either side of me. Carl sat in one of the chairs. Chuck surprised everyone and sat in Carl’s lap which drew some smiles. Chuck then asked, “So, what do we want to do?” Chris spoke up, “Why don’t we play Truth or Dare. I’ll go first with a truth. I’m gay, Chuck. I didn’t come out to you because I’m not ready to come out yet, and the fewer people who know, the less chance there is that someone would let it slip. I should have told you sooner, but it never seemed to be the right time. I trust you won’t say anything to anyone outside this room.” The whole room was silent for a very long time until Chuck said, “Thanks, Chris for trusting me with that. I had my suspicions, especially seeing the underwear and lube next to the sofa earlier.” Elijah and Chris both turned red, and Chris said, “Shit! I was hoping they were under the sofa.” Elijah then admitted, “I totally forgot to grab the lube.” Chuck then asked, “So, are the two of you playing around or are you in a relationship?” I interrupted, “I think it’s my turn for a truth. I found Chris’ briefs and the lube before we headed over to the Reynolds. I was hoping no one else had seen them. The fact of the matter is, they are in a relationship, together and with me. We’ve decided to become a throuple. That’s what I was going to tell you later, Carl. Now that everyone is out, I can say it in front of everyone here. Carl suddenly had a huge smile on his face and said, “Congratulations, you three. I don’t know how that will work out in the long term, but I think Jeremy will stop being so tense about you two now. I grinned, knowing Carl was right and Chris and Elijah laughed, knowing I had been stressing out over them. They caught me off guard when they both kissed me. Chuck and Carl then kissed each other. As we continued our three-way kiss, Chuck spoke up, “My turn! I choose Dare! I dare us all to get naked and celebrate these two relationships.” Elijah asked, “You want us all to have an orgy?” Chuck smiled and said, “That would be fun but maybe another time. Right now, I just want my boyfriend Carl and you three can do whatever you want together as what you call a throuple. I’m just saying we do it here in front of each other instead of hiding in separate bedrooms.” I looked at Chris for his reaction. His face was a bit flushed, but he shrugged his shoulders, then the clothes began to fly.

Once Elijah, Chris and I were down to just our briefs, we decided to have a little fun. Elijah and I got down on our knees on either side of Chris and using only our teeth, we pulled Elijah’s briefs (actually my briefs) down around his ankles. Chuck yelled, “I always wanted to see that butt naked. I’m definitely not disappointed. Nice cock too.” Chris seemed to be in continuous blush mode. After Chris kicked off his briefs he moved to his knees. Elijah stood up and Chris and I did the same to his briefs. Carl and Chuck were already naked but were now just watching us undress each other. Carl gave a cat whistle when Elijah’s briefs dropped around his ankles. Lastly, Elijah and Chris mouthed my briefs down to applause from Carl and Chuck. We laughed and then got down into a triangle with me sucking Chris’ cock, Chris sucking Elijah’s and Elijah sucking mine. Chuck moved to the floor in front of Carl sucking his cock as he sat in the chair. After several minutes, the three of us switched around so I was now sucking Elijah’s cock, he was sucking Chris’ and Chris was sucking mine. A few minutes later, I felt a wet finger probing at my rosebud and seconds later it was inside me. I moaned on Elijah’s cock and after a second finger entered me, I started to suspect Chris had a plan in mind. Once Chris had worked three fingers in my hole for a few minutes, he pulled his mouth from my cock and instructed, “Elijah, get on the sofa on your back. Jeremy, climb over him in a sixty-nine. We did as Chris directed and noticed that Carl and Chuck had traded places and Carl was now sucking Chuck’s cock. As Elijah and I began sucking each other, I heard Chuck say, “Yeah, Chris! Fuck that ass!” Then I felt Chris’ cock sliding between my buns. I moaned on Elijah’s cock as I felt Chris’ cock pushing inside me. Once again I heard Chuck, “That looks so fucking hot, Chris. Fuck his ass good. Gimme your cock, Carl. Fuck me as Chris fucks Jeremy.” Before long Chris was pistoning in and out of me as I moaned and groaned in ecstasy on Elijah’s precum-leaking cock. Chuck was grunting and begging Carl to fuck him harder. I was getting close as Chris was hitting my prostate on each tug and push. Apparently Elijah was enjoying my mouth vibrations on his cock as I felt his cock harden while at the same time, Chris said, “I’m getting close!” I whimpered as my own balls began churning. Then Elijah’s cock throbbed, sending a rope of cum into my mouth. It was as if his cum went right through me as my own cock blasted a rope of cum into Elijah’s mouth. “Oh fuck!”, I heard Chris cry out and then felt his cock blasting his baby makers into my guts. The three of us grunted and moaned as cum filled our orifices. I vaguely heard Chuck begging Carl, “Fuckin’ slam my ass, Carl. Harder! Fuck me! Breed my ass!” Then Carl said, “Fuck yeah, Chuck! Here it comes! Fuck!” Spent, I collapsed on top of Elijah with his saliva-coated cock against my cheek and Chris collapsed onto my back as we caught our breath. I could see Carl was still buried in Chuck’s hole and Chuck’s chest and face were splattered with cum. Chuck smiled over at me and gave a thumbs up and I smiled back. Then Carl moved forward, and he and Chuck kissed. Chris slowly pulled his still-stiff cock from me and moved off me so I could get off of Elijah. The three of us then kissed, sharing some of Elijah and my cum. Then we looked over to Carl and Chuck. They were watching us with grins on their faces. We grinned back and Chuck said, “That was so fuckin’ lit! Hot as all hell!” All five of us then got up. Carl stepped over in front of me and said, “Congratulations, Jeremy.”, before kissing me. After we broke the kiss, Carl moved to Chris and did the same to him. Chuck was watching and then shrugged as he stepped in front of me and we said congratulations to each other before kissing. He still had some of his cum on his chin and I licked a little of it before we kissed. I’m sure he could taste Elijah and my cum as we kissed. He then moved to Chris as Carl moved to kiss Elijah. Chris’ eyes went wide as Chuck squeezed his buns. As they broke their kiss, Chuck grinned and said, “I was always hoping to do that. Chuck then kissed Elijah and after squeezing his buns, said, “I still want this butt, but now I also want its twin.” He indicated who by a motion with his head in Chris’ direction. Then he said to me, “And even though we already had each other, I’ll never tire of your amazing ass.” I laughed and said, “I guess we should clean up and then hang out for a bit before Elijah has to head out. As the three of us headed toward my ensuite, Carl said, “Just look at those three amazing butts.” Chris’ face turned red once more.

As we were stepping into the shower, Elijah said, “I guess that completes the consummation of our throuple then.” I said, “Not quite. I have one more breeding to complete.” I then smacked Chris’ bare butt and he yelped. We washed each other with care and then dried each other. The smiles never left our faces.

We came out from my bedroom at the same time as Carl and Chris stepped out of the main bathroom. We each grabbed a beer except Elijah because of having to drive back to his campus. He drank a soda. We went out and sat on the front porch and waved to the neighbors walking by or walking their dogs. They always waved to us now and we always waved back. As Elijah was preparing to leave, I received a call from Josh. He wanted to know if he could visit next weekend and if we minded if he brought a ‘friend’.

 

End of Chapter 40