How I Got My Revenge

Chapter 38

Progressions

We entered the house, and after getting rid of our empty cans we headed toward my room. Then we heard it, “Fuck yeah! Gimme that cock, Chuck! Fuck me!” Elijah and I looked at each other, grinning. Once I closed my bedroom door behind us, I asked Elijah, “Do you still want my swimmers inside you?” He practically ripped off my clothes, “You’re damn right I do!” I laughed and said, “Shhh! Quiet down.” He replied, “Are you kidding me? You heard those two.” By that time, we were both naked and Elijah was pushing me backward toward my bed. Once the back of my legs hit the side of the bed, Elijah pressed up against me and we kissed while our stiff cocks ground together and leaked precum. Soon our cocks were gliding together, lubed up by our precum which was oozing from them. Suddenly, Elijah pushed forward, and I fell backward onto the bed with Elijah on top of me. Elijah broke our kiss and we both laughed as we looked into each other’s eyes. Then Elijah slowly worked his way kissing and licking from my chin downward to my throbbing cock. He teased it for a little, just barely licking the underside and grinning as it jumped at the touch of his tongue. Then he began licking my balls, soaking them in his saliva while keeping eye contact with me. I smiled at him, enjoying the feel of his tongue lapping at my balls and the look in his eyes. He seemed to be enjoying every bit of what he was doing and soon moved back to the base of my cock. At first, he resumed teasing it by barely touching the tip of his tongue against the underside, causing it to jump each time in anticipation. I groaned, “Stop teasing me. You’re driving me crazy.” He grinned and his eyes had a mischievous sparkle in them. Then his tongue made full contact as he licked from the base of my cock to the precum-oozing tip. As his tongue left the tip, my cock jumped and a glob of precum poured out like at the end of a climax when the last of your cum oozes out. Elijah grinned as he saw it and eagerly licked it from my hard abs, then took the head of my cock into his mouth and began licking all around it. I inhaled sharply as he slid his lips downward and my cock went to the back of his throat. He choked from it making me laugh, but then he went right back to it. Each time he went down, he took more of my cock until his nose was barely tickling my pubic bush. It wasn’t long before I was getting close, and I pulled his head off my cock. He grinned and said, “I know, you were getting close. I was about to stop. He then grabbed the tube of lube off the table, squeezed some out, and worked a finger into his tight hole. He wiped his finger on a napkin and then climbed on the bed on all fours. He looked back at me in anticipation as he arched his lower back slightly, causing his hot butt to stick out teasingly. I smiled and teased him, “Are you sure you want this.” He grinned and said, “Stop teasing me and shove that big cock in me, Jeremy.” I grinned mischievously before dragging the head of my cock up and down between his firm, muscular buns. Then I pressed against his hot hole and I heard him inhale deeply and then he said, “Take my ass, Jeremy. Fuck me deep. Breed me. I want your baby makers to flood my hole.” My cock throbbed in anticipation and then I pressed against his tightness. The head of my cock breached his entrance and he groaned, “Fuuuck yesss.” I slowly sank in deeper until my pubic bone was pressed tightly against his hard buns. I kissed and nibbled at his neck and jaw and then he turned, and our lips met. Our tongues dueled back and forth as I began tugging out and then plunging back in. Over and over my cock moved back and forth inside him as we continued to kiss as he emitted soft moans into my mouth. I wasn’t hurried in my thrusts. I could tell I was hitting all the right spots by his reactions and moans against my mouth as we continued to kiss. I was giving him what he wanted, and I realized that Elijah was giving me what I needed. This was warm and personal, not just some wild group sex. Not that I didn’t enjoy our fun together with threesomes and sometimes foursomes, having wild guilt free sex. But it was nice to have this; passionate, personal, meaningful, love making. Yes, we weren’t just having sex. I pulled out of him and asked Elijah to flip onto his back. I wanted to see his face as we made love. We were making love. Yes, it’s true that this was not the first time I was making love. I’ve made love quite a few times beginning with Kayla. I made love with Carl. Now our love had morphed into what it had actually been from the start, more brotherly than as lovers. I’d always love him, but we’d never end up as lovers, not that we still wouldn’t have sex, just in a playful way. Yeah, I know, strange, right. It wasn’t strange for us though. We’d come to understand our feelings for each other and the boundaries. We’d always be there for each other, just as brothers would and maybe more than brothers. Then I had made love to Elijah, even while rejecting him because of the physical distance between us. At the time, I was still mourning over my breakup with Kayla and the thought of another long distance relationship frightened me. I also made love with Chris, and it was fantastic, but it was fantastic with Elijah as well. The only difference was miles. Now, once again, Elijah and I were making love. I didn’t want to choose, and Carl had convinced me I didn’t need to choose, at least for now. For now, I would love them both as fully as I could. I’m not talking about just sex here. I wanted to let them know that I loved them both so deeply that it hurt. It hurts thinking that at some point I may have to choose between them. I didn’t want that time to come but knew it may. Suddenly I was brought out of my momentary self-reflection. Elijah was biting my bottom lip while whimpering, “Ohhhh, fuuuck. Fuuuuck meee. Jeremeee. Oh my God! I’m cumminnnnggg!” I realized Elijah’s right hand was on the back of my head, and his left was on my right butt cheek trying to pull me deeper inside him. Then I felt his rigid cock pulsing between us and his warm, creamy seed filling in the gap between our bodies like a cream-filled donut (éclair). His sphincter pulsed in time to his ejaculations which brought me to my own orgasm, “Fuck yes, Elijah! I’m cumming with you! Take my seed!” Elijah was looking into my eyes as he said, “Fuck yeah, Jeremy! Breed me. Flood me with your baby-makers!” I stared into his eyes as I flooded his guts with my seed. As our orgasms ebbed, I lowered down on top of Elijah and we resumed our kiss. Eventually, my flaccid cock was ejected from Elijah and after several more minutes, we broke our kiss. We smiled at each other and then Elijah said, “That was so fucking lit, Jeremy. Thanks.” I rolled off him and laid beside him and said, “Yeah, it was awesome.” We turned our heads toward each other, gave each other a quick kiss, and then just smiled contentedly. I broke the silence, “We should get in the shower and wash up.” Elijah replied, “Yeah, but first..” He gave me a mischievous look, got up and climbed over me in a sixty-nine position but with his head more aligned with my abs than of my crotch. Elijah leaned down and began licking his cum from me. I followed his lead and leaned up and began licking his cum from his abs as well. Once we were done giving each other tongue baths, Elijah swung around onto his side, and we kissed some more. Elijah broke the kiss and smiled at me. I smiled back and asked him, “Are you ready for that shower now?” He just nodded and we got up and went into my ensuite. I turned on the shower and once the water heated up, we stepped in and lathered each other’s bodies up. While washing my back, Elijah asked, “Remember the night in Josh’s parents’ shower when I pleaded with you to let me fuck you?” I laughed and replied, “How could I forget that?” Elijah said, “When you finally said yes, I almost shot my load before I was even in you. That’s how excited I was getting to fuck this perfect ass of your.” I looked back at him in fake anger and asked, “Did you just call me an ass?” We both laughed. We were both hard again by the time we were finished and laughed as we playfully dried each other. We probably could have gone another round, but instead we climbed into bed and I snuggled up behind Elijah as the big spoon with my still rigid cock wedged between his firm, muscular cheeks and my left arm wrapped around him. He pushed back into me and giggled, then turned his head back toward me and we kissed before saying “Goodnight” to each other.

Carl decided to grab Chuck and him another drink before going to bed. Chuck had told him he owed him for Chuck not getting to fuck Elijah. So, Carl bottomed for Chuck for a change. Carl didn’t bottom very often but enjoyed it every now and then. Tonight, he had enjoyed it a lot. Chuck was hitting his prostate constantly and he was loving every minute of it. He hoped Jeremy and Elijah were still outside when he was loudly begging Chuck to fuck him harder. Carl was not normally that vocal. As he was returning with the drinks, he heard Elijah’s voice and quietly approached Jeremy’s bedroom door. He listened as Elijah was moaning and begging Jeremy to fuck him harder. Against his better judgement, he carefully opened the door a crack a peeked inside to see Jeremy pounding Elijah. He smiled as he saw them staring into each other’s eyes. This was why he had steered the earlier sex the way he had. Well, that and the fact that he was having some feelings of his own for Chuck. He quietly closed the door, picked the drinks back up, and took them in for he and Chuck to have a nightcap before bed. At one point in their relationship Carl had thought he and Jeremy might end up in a relationship. Well, they kind of were to some extent, but Carl had felt some guilt. He felt like he was taking advantage of Jeremy’s vulnerability after his breakup with his sister, Kayla. He and Jeremy had talked a lot about the issue and they had come to the understanding that their feelings were more brotherly, but would continue to enjoy having sex together. Carl understood that Elijah had strong feelings for Jeremy and so did Chris. He was a little jealous that those two hot guys had the hots for Jeremy who was smoking hot himself. He almost wished he had the dilemma that Jeremy had, having to choose between the Elijah and Chris. Almost, because he understood how bad it hurt Jeremy to think about hurting either one of them. He had seen the hurt in those eyes several times. The first was the day he shared the news of the letter from Kayla that their relationship was over. Then he saw it when they discussed their own relationship after it was revealed that Elijah had crushed on him for years. Carl’s own heart ached on that day. He loved Jeremy and wanted to see him happy, and it was painful to them both as they admitted to each other that their relationship was not that of lovers so much as more like brothers and best friends. That pain though was blunted by the understanding that they would always have each other’s backs. This was why Carl had a smile when he saw Jeremy and Elijah staring into each other’s eyes as they made love. Carl’s smile grew wider as he approached his bedroom door with the hope that maybe he and Chuck might develop that kind of relationship.

As Carl entered his bedroom with the drinks, Chuck grinned at him and said, “Someone looks happy.” Carl handed Chuck one of the glasses and then climbed onto the bed next to him and said, “Yeah, I am. I had fun tonight.” Before Carl could say anything further, Chuck said, “Yeah, me too but I regret some things I did.” Carl asked, “Like what?” Chuck said, “Well, I was a little buzzed earlier and tried to come on to Chris.” Carl said, “Yeah, I think we all noticed you rubbing your leg against his.” Chuck said, “Yeah, but before he left, when I was getting drinks, he went into Jeremy’s room. When he came out, I told him I was sorry he was leaving. He went to shake my hand and I hugged him instead. Then I grabbed his butt.” Carl was surprised, “Oh shit! What did he do?” Chuck said, “He pushed my hand off and walked outside without saying much of anything.” Carl smiled and said, “He does have a pretty fine ass.” Chuck said, “Yeah, but that was a pretty stupid move on my part. I wouldn’t have blamed him if he would have punched me in the mouth. As far as I know, he’s straight.” Carl asked, “So, if he wasn’t straight, would you want to date him?” Chuck laughed, “Don’t get me wrong, if I had the chance, I’d definitely fuck him. He's not really my type though. He’s got a really hot body and great looks, but he’s too young for my tastes. I have my eye on somebody else.” Carl was afraid to ask, but did anyway, “Elijah?” Chuck laughed again, “Nah. He’s another hottie with a great ass that I’d love to fuck. He’s also got a quick wit, but no.” Carl was relieved and then suddenly thought that maybe Jeremy had a third guy chasing him and his happy smile suddenly vanished. Chuck asked, “Where’d that sweet smile go?” Carl shrugged. Chuck then said, “You know, for a really smart guy, you can be pretty thick sometimes.” Carl gave Chuck a puzzled look and Chuck gave him a quick kiss, then said, “The guy I have my eye on is cute. He’s athletic and I had thought was pretty smart up until a minute ago.” Carl’s eyes opened wide as he asked, “You mean?” Chuck just smiled and nodded his head. Carl then kissed Chuck and then said, “You just brought my happy face back. You don’t know how happy you just made me.” Chuck’s smile grew wider, “Your reaction just made my whole night.” They both set their drinks down and began kissing.

I woke up still spooning Elijah, and hard as a rock. Elijah was obviously already awake. He was moving so that my cock was gliding smoothly between his firm, muscular buns. I must have been leaking precum for a while since my cock and the area between his buns was already soaked in it. I whispered in his ear, “I don’t know how long you’ve been at this but I’m about to explode.” Elijah suddenly flipped around and moved down saying, “I’m not gonna let you waste it.” Then took my precum-soaked cock into his warm mouth. It wasn’t long before I was pumping my seed into Elijah’s mouth, “Fuck yeah. What a way to wake up. My turn.” I started to maneuver to Elijah’s cock, but he instead drew me in to a kiss to share my cum. We swapped it back and forth until it was consumed. Then I pushed him back on the bed and worked my way down, kissing and licking my way until I reached Elijah’s throbbing cock. I teasingly licked it like a lollipop, making sure to include his nutsack. I looked up into Elijah’s eyes as I took his cock into my mouth and slowly went down until my nose was buried in his pubic bush. Elijah smiled at me and said, “Holy fuck! I can’t believe you took my whole cock in your throat. This is so fucking hot!” I then began working his cock while playing with his balls. I had kept my eyes on his the entire time until he said, “Oh fuck! I’m going to fucking cum!”, and his eyes rolled up and he leaned his head back. I felt his nuts tighten and then his cock seemed to swell before it shot a wad of cum into the back of my throat. It felt like it could have gone right through my skull like a shotgun blast. It was followed by another and another. I had to swallow or allow it to seep from my mouth. Eventually, the blasts of his cum slowed and his breathing along with it. He raised his head back up and our eyes met once more as he smiled and said, “Holy fuckin’ A, Jeremy! That was so fuckin’ lit!” I pulled off his cock and made my way up on top of him and we shared a cummy kiss once again. We had consumed his cum but continued making out for a while before I glanced at the clock and realized it was only 5AM. I rolled off Elijah and laid next to him and said, “I can’t believe you woke me up this early, but thanks, it was a fantastic way to wake up.” Elijah turned toward me, and we briefly kissed again. Then Elijah surprised me saying, “I know you’re in a tough spot trying not to hurt us. I get it, but I’m not planning on going anywhere unless you tell me to. I understand what you see in Chris. Fuck, I’d be all over him if I didn’t have you as a choice. I really like him, but if I had to choose, you’d get my vote every time. I’m not saying this to pressure you. I just want you to know how I feel. I’m willing to share you with Chris if that’s what you want. Hell, I think it’s pretty hot when the three of us are together. I don’t know if I love him, but I do like him a lot. I guess I’ll shut up now. I guess I just ruined our great morning.” I considered what Elijah was saying and replied, “You didn’t ruin anything. In fact, I appreciate what you just said and I’m really glad you said it. Yes, I’m totally fucked if I’d have to choose right now between you two. I don’t think I could make a choice right now. I love you both. Yes, I LOVE both of you!” Elijah sighed and asked, “What about Carl?” I smiled and replied, “Carl and I have a complicated relationship, but we’ve come to an understanding that we’re never going to be lovers. We love each other deeply, but it’s more a brotherly and best friend kind of love with benefits.” Elijah smiled and said, “Kind of like me and Josh.” I smiled at him and said, "Yeah, probably. Since we’re up, why don’t we grab a cup of coffee and surprise Carl and Chuck with breakfast.” Elijah grinned and replied, “I’d rather just stay in bed and dine on you some more but it would be nice to surprise them with breakfast.

I got a pair of my boxers and pulled them on then threw Elijah a pair. He grinned and said, “Thanks.” We went into the kitchen and Elijah started making coffee while I got out bacon, sausage links, leftover boiled potatoes for home fries and eggs, and began making breakfast. After I got breakfast started and sipped on my coffee, I rounded up the dirty clothes and threw some in the washing machine to get a head start on the morning chores. Soon the smell of breakfast was wafting in the air and I pulled out the bread to begin making toast. Elijah took the loaf of bread, “I’ll take care of making the toast so you can concentrate on cooking breakfast.” I grinned and said, “Sooner or later you’ll have to learn how to cook.” Elijah grinned and said, “Yeah, unless I hook up with a guy who already knows how.” I laughed, understanding his insinuation. I was looking over at Elijah when he suddenly looked out from the kitchen and his jaw dropped, and then he said, “Jeremy, look.” I turned in the direction he was staring, and I was suddenly smiling as Carl and Chuck were walking toward us, holding hands.

 

End of Chapter 38