Unexpected

It was almost noon when we got out of bed. I grabbed a jockstrap in my drawer and put it on, wearing nothing else. I enjoyed walking around almost naked in front Chase, I felt like I was his little boy toy. I remembered Max was supposed to come to my place tonight. I had to decide if I wanted to go out with Chase and hunt straight brats to dominate or stay here and have a romantic night with Max. As I was trying to make a choice, Max texted me that he wasn’t feeling well and had to postpone our date night. I told him to take care and to text me if he needed anything. I felt bad that he was sick, but it was kind of a good timing. Now I could go out with Chase without feeling guilty. I know it’s kinda selfish of me, but I just couldn’t resist my pulsions. Chase stayed in his briefs as I made him coffee. “Who would’ve thought I ‘d be serving coffee to the who just forced me to have sex with him huh?” I said jokingly as I handed him his cup. “I sure wasn’t expecting things to end up like this, but I’m glad it did…” He replied with a wink and took a sip. I sat beside him and caressed his thick hairy thighs, already wanting him in me again.

I slipped my hand in his briefs and grabbed his cock. He smiled as spread his legs and caressed my bulge. “My little boy’s already hungry huh?” He said as he squeezed my stiffening cock. “So hungry, you got me addicted daddy…” I replied as I got off my chair and knelt between his legs. He looked down at me with a big naughty smile as I bit the waistband of his briefs and pulled them down with my teeth. His cock sprung up and slapped my face. We giggled as I lapped on his shaft and pulled out my cock. I jacked off as I started sucking his cock. “Mmmmm yea that’s it… good boy!” He said as he pressed my head deeper on him. I loved the musky taste of his cock, the perfect treat to start the day. At this point I was glad he broke into my apartment. I paused sucking his cock and licked my fingers. I wanted to finger his ass. I wasn’t sure he would let me, but even if he didn’t, I knew I’d enjoy his punishment anyway haha. So I engulfed his cock back in my mouth as I slipped my finger between his cheeks. I was surprised when he spread them apart with his hands.

I touched his hole and started rubbing it. It was so smooth. I licked my finger again and pushed it in. He moaned as I started fingering his ass. He was super tight. “Daddy loves what your doing… not many had this chance you know…” He said as he clenched his hole. It was so hot to get the chance to play with his dom top hole. The fact that he was submitting his ass to me was such a turn on. “You like having your little boy’s fingers up your ass daddy?” I said as I added a second finger. He groaned as his cock twitched. “Fuck yea boy! Come on, add another one, stretch daddy’s hole!” He replied as he put his legs up on the table, giving me better access to his ass. At this point I was hornier than I’ve ever been. Chase looked so sexy with legs spread open and his rock hard cock sticking straight up. I inserted a third finger and started fucking his ass as I stroke his cock. He pinched his nipples as he closed his eyes and tilted his head back.

I felt his hole relaxing more and more. “You know what, get up boy…” He said as he stood up and pulled me up. He laid on his back on the couch and lifted his legs. “Show daddy what you’re capable of…” He said as I got leaned on top of him. My cock was harder than ever, already slick with my precum. My heart was beating so fast. I pressed my cock on his hole and let the head pop in. I was about to take it slow, but he grabbed me by the waist and pulled me balls deep inside him. “Uurrggg fuck yea boy! Gosh you’re big…” He moaned as I stayed there a little. We made out as I started thrusting back and forth. Fucking such a big strong man was the ultimate dream for me. I fucked him harder and faster. I was on cloud nine. “That’s it boy! Fuck daddy’s ass! Show me you’re big boy!” He yelped as I railed his ass. He jacked off vigorously, moaning louder. “Ohhh daddy your ass feels so good! I won’t last long!” I said as I felt I was getting closer.

“It’s okay boy, daddy’s about to cum… let’s shoot our loads together, fill my ass…” He said as he moaned, looking me straight in the eyes. We both came almost instantly. He spurted cum all over his hairy chest and his face while I filled his ass with my load. I shot several times. “Fuck yea… good boy!” He said as he wiped some cum on his chest and licked it. I leaned in and licked his chest clean. It was so delicious. “Look at you, such a well behaved boy…” He said as we kissed, my cock still inside him. Some cum leaked out of him as I pulled out. His cock was still hard and sensitive. I licked his cock head and sucked on his cock a little. “Uughh fuck ughhh damn! Mmffff” He moaned as he gripped on the couch, his body twitched as his toes twisted. I loved teasing his spent cock. “Thanks for letting me fuck you, that was amazing daddy…” I said as I laid on top of him. We were both out of breath. He ran his fingers through my hair and kissed my forehead.

We both fell asleep on the couch. He woke me up about an hour later. “Wakey wakey, come on we have to get ready and look out for tonight’s prey…” He said as he gently shook me. I got up and rubbed my eyes. “You look so cute, come here and give me a kiss…” He said as he stood up and held me in his arms. He squeezed my ass as we kissed. We went to my room and got dressed. “So… how do you usually prepare? I know you saw me and followed me, but do you just randomly choose a location? Or…?” I asked as he gathered his stuff back in his bag. “Well, usually I try to spot some hot guys and, depending on their shape and size I approach them differently, what type of guys would you like to play with tonight?” He answered as he sat on the edge of my bed. “Errm I don’t know… maybe we could find a tall, large straight stud? You know a cocky brat who would never be submissive… We could do to him what you did to me…” I replied as my cock stiffened a little. “Hahaha ok well, let’s get us some stud! You sure know what you want…” He replied as he pulled me in, making me fall on top of him. He grabbed me and sat back up, sitting me on his lap.

We were both rock hard and his shirt was still unbuttoned. I caressed his chest, squeezing his plump pecs. I leaned in and started making out with him again. It seemed like I couldn’t get enough of this man I just met. “Okay okay now, you know I would fuck that sweet ass right away, but we need to spare ourselves for tonight…” He said as he giggled and grabbed my ass with both hands. I was still naked from the waist down, so his fingers brushed against my hole. My cock pressed on his hairy abs, literally leaking precum. I moaned as he teased my hole and licked his finger before pushing it in. I started thrusting my hips, stroking my cock on his abs. “You like that huh? Like when daddy plays with your tight hole?” He whispered as he inserted a second finger. Soon he was finger fucking my ass. “Mmmfff yesss… feels so good daddy!” I replied moaning. “Are you gonna cum for daddy?” He asked as his fingers hit my prostate. “Yessss mmmmmmffff fuuuuck I’m cuu… I’m cumming!” I replied as I shot jets of cum between our abs, some of it flew up hitting his face. “Haha good boy! You’re an insatiable slut huh?” He said as he wiggled his fingers in my ass and rubbed my sensitive cock head with the other. I gasped as my body spasmed with pleasure.

He lift me up in his arms and carried me to the shower. We fondled each other some more as we soaped our bodies. I got on my knees and engulfed his massive cock. “Fuck yea… my sweet baby boy….” He said as he put a hand on my head. I held onto his hairy buns as I sucked his cock. In no time he was moaning louder as he shot his load down my throat. I swallowed his delicious juice as I kept eye contact with him. “Such a good boy…” He said as he smiled and ran his fingers through my wet hair. We dried up and got dressed once again.  “Let’s go and get you some accessories, then we’ll go hunting” Chase said as he put on his pants. I put on some tight navy shorts and a light pink t-shirt along with my navy laceless shoes. Once we were both dressed, he grabbed his bag and off we were. Funny how quickly I went from being scared of him to being attracted to him. I couldn’t stop questioning myself. Was I stupid? Or was I just accepting my feelings? I know this isn’t something common, but I was thrilled to try something new and just going with it. We took my car and he showed me to a sex shop a few blocks away. He put a hand on my thigh and gently caressed it as I drove. I found myself feeling safe with him and actually having butterflies in my stomach. At first I didn’t want to let myself feel that way for him because of Max, but little did I know much I would fall for Chase.

We got in front of the store and got out of the car. I’ve never been to a sex shoo before, so I just followed him. We got to a section with all kinds of outfits. He stopped in front of a display filled with all sorts of masks. “Ahh that’s it, that’ll be perfect!” Chase said as he picked up a leather mask. “We should get you a harness too, you’d be so sexy….“ He continued as I followed him. I was new to this so I decided to let him choose for me. He pick a black and red harness and held it front of me. “Gosh I can’t wait to see you in that…” He said as he bit his lip. I giggle as we headed to checkout. As the cashier scanned the items, he gave us a few looks and smiles. “Looks like you guys are going to have some fun…” He said as he raised his eyebrows. “Haha we sure will… he’s my little toy boy now” Chase replied as he wrapped his arm over my shoulder and squeezed me onto him. “Well you’re a lucky boy, I wish I had a daddy to own me like that…” He answered back as he looked at us and winked. “Well you’re a cute guy, you won’t have trouble getting one” Chase replied as he winked. The cashier blushed as he handed him the bag. “Hopefully I’ll see you guys soon?” The cashier said just before we reached the door. “Hopefully…” I replied smiling, intending he would see us soon.

“I thought about it and, there are a lot of jerks at the gym where I workout, maybe we could go hunting there?” I suggested as we got in my car. “Well, do you think one of them could recognize you? We gotta be careful with this…” He replied as he fastened his seatbelt. “Yea… forget this, I just remembered I recently started dating a guy who goes there too, what if we just wait outside discreetly and follow one of them like you did with me?” I replied. “Alright, sounds like a good plan! Someone’s a fast learner haha” He said as he patted my shoulder. I giggled as I took off to the gym. I parked at a spot far enough not to be seen, but still close enough to see any potential catch. “So how do you want to proceed?” I asked while we wait. “Since it’s not dark yet, we have to be very careful not be seen, we could follow him around and wait for the right time to take action…” He replied as we watched several guys walk passed us and enter the gym. As I said, mostly cocky boys strutting and showing off their muscles with tight shorts and tank top.

As we waited he caressed my thigh with one hand and played with my hair with the other. As much as he was rough with me last night, now he was all sweet and thoughtful. “You’re so beautiful boy… I just wanna kiss you all over your body… you do know I’m gonna need my daily dose of you from now on right?” He said with warm silly voice. I giggled as I blushed. We kissed as I put a hand on his chest. “I’m glad you broke into my apartment…” I said as I laughed. “My first intentions were purely sexual, but I actually enjoy being with you today…” He replied as we both smiled at each other. In the middle of this kinda romantic moment, one of the cockiest guy of the gym came out. He was wearing tight jeans, a burgundy polo and white sneakers. If he wasn’t such a jerk he’d be the dream boyfriend. Nice round ass, large muscled body, 6’ft tall, blond hair and hazel eyes. “Him! He deserves to know he’s not as though as he think he is…” I said as I turned on the engine. “That guy is not only cocky, but he always makes comments to undermine you, plus he’s kinda homophobic.” “Well, seems like we have our guy! Let him distance us a little, then follow him discreetly” Chase said as the guy drove passed us in his car. I waited a few seconds and took off.

We followed him for about 20 minutes until he stopped at bar. It was now a little after 6. “Do we go inside? We could get a drink, not like get drunk, just a drink” I suggested. “Do you think he could recognize you?” Chase asked as he unbuckled his seatbelt. “No chance, I’m no one to him…“ I replied as I got out of the car. We walked in the bar, the guy was at a table with a group of a few guys just as cocky as him. Chase and I sat at table in a discreet spot. As we kept an eye on him, we talked and got to know each other better. He told me he’s a retired hockey player and now running a small sports store. “You certainly have the shape of a hockey player still…” I replied as I squeezed his biceps. He giggled as he blushed. I told him  moved here to get away from the homophobic environment of my previous university and that I was now studying at the academy of arts, still trying to figure out what I really wanted to do. “You’re still young, don’t rush yourself…” He replied as he held my hand. As we talked I saw Max walk in the bar holding hands with another guy. I was kinda pissed, he told me he was sick. Obviously he wasn’t… I really thought he was special.

“Something’s wrong? You seem upset all of a sudden…” Chase asked with worried eyes. “It’s nothing, it’s just, that guy over there, we recently started dating and he canceled our plans saying he was sick… but there he is with another guy…tsss” I replied as I rolled my eyes. He looked at Max then back at me. “How long have you been dating?” He asked as he looked at Max. “Well, we’ve only had one date in person, but we’ve been talking fo a while… We’re not boyfriends yet…” I replied, realizing that I might be overreacting. “I know, I know… it’s stupid for me to think he wasn’t talking with other guys… it’s not like we’re tied in any way…” I added as Chase laughed at me. “Just relax… that only means you can have fun and fool around too…” He replied with a wink. After all he was right, plus I had a lot of fun ahead tonight. We ended up having a few more beers, but we controlled ourselves so we didn’t get drunk.

We drank water while our prey was still having beers and shots. At one point he paid his bill and waved his friends goodbye. We waited for him to walk outside then followed him. A taxi was already waiting for him, so we got in my car and followed him. The drive to his place was familiar, I realized he lived only a block away from mine. The taxi stopped in front a nice building and he walked to the main entrance. Chase grabbed his bag and tossed me my mask. “Wait, get over here and bend over…” He said holding as he pulled out a butt plug. I smiled as I went around to the passenger side and bent on the seat. He pulled down my shorts and spat on the plug before gently shoving it in my ass. He then pulled my shorts completely off leaving me in my jockstrap. “From now and until I say so, you’re my slutty assistant, you do as I say ok?” He said as he put my shorts in his bag. I nodded yes as my cock stiffened. I kinda enjoyed being butt naked in public with the plug stuck in my ass.

I put on my mask and we headed inside. We saw him waiting for an elevator. He pressed the penthouse button. Jeez who was that guy? Penthouse?! At least we knew where we were headed now. Once he got in and the doors closed, we got on the next one and got to the penthouse. He was still unlocking his door when the elevator opened. We let him get in before leaving the elevator. We got to the door and tried it. He left the door unlocked. We slowly opened it until we were sure the way was clear. We heard the shower running and walked in. That place was huge and nicely decorated. And clean, like hotel clean. I wondered what he was doing for work to afford such a place. The bathroom door was left ajar and we could see him showering. Water running down his back to his bubble butt. His balls dangling between his legs. My heart was racing like never. I knew what we were doing was wrong, even illegal, but it gave me such a thrill. My cock was so hard my jock struggled to keep it in. “That’s quite a stud you got us boy…” Chase whispered as the guy dried up.

He wrapped the towel around his waist and headed towards the door. We quickly hid in his walk-in wardrobe. We heard footsteps but didn’t know where he went. So we waited until it stopped. We quietly walked out and looked for him. We walked in front of his bedroom and saw him sitting in front of his computer, jacking off to some porn. That was just perfect, his cock would already be hard for us to enjoy. We got in without making a noise and Chase quickly grabbed his arms and held them behind the chair. “WHAT THE FUCK?!!! WHO… WHO ARE YOU?? GET OFF ME!!!!” The guy screamed as he tried to escape Chase. I grabbed the handcuffs in the bag and quickly handcuffed him. “Don’t worry we won’t hurt you or rob you, we just want to have some fun…” I said as I turned the chair towards me and grabbed his cock. “Don’t fucking touch me you creep!” He said as he spat. “Watch your tone! Tonight you’re our little bitch! Understood?” I added as slapped him. I could see Chase smiling through the hole of his mask. I squeezed his balls tighter until he begged to stop. “Okay okay! Please please… what do you want?! I-I I can give you money! I have lots of money! Take all you want! Please don’t hurt me!” He begged as I could see fear in his eyes. It was such a rush to have this power over such a big cocky guy.

“Just relax… promise we won’t hurt you, just do as we say okay?” Chase said as he caressed the guy’s chest from behind, sniffing his neck. “Heeeelp!!! Someone!!” He yelled as he squirmed on the chair. “Haha it’s useless… no one can hear you here, now stop yelling or else we’ll punish you!” Chase said as he squeezed his face. “Fuck you bastard!!!” He replied angrily. Chase slapped him so hard he got dizzy for a few seconds. “Be respectful to your master! Have I made myself clear?!” Chase asked as he pulled his pants down along with his briefs. The guy weakly nodded yes as I got on my knees and caressed his torso and thighs. Chase then brought his cock close to the guy’s face. “Now, what’s your name pretty boy?” He asked as he gently stroke his cock. “Ermm I I I’m Spencer… ” He replied with a shaky voice. “Well Spencer, tonight you belong to us, just let us do our thing and no one will get hurt alright?” Chase asked on a fatherly tone. Spencer just nodded yes with a resigned look. “Good boy…” Chase replied as he rubbed his cock on his lips. “Boy your lips are so soft… Open your mouth, come on…” He asked as he grabbed his chin and pulled it, prying his mouth open. He opened his mouth and stuck his tongue out. Chase slowly shoved his cock in as he held onto his head. Spencer gagged a couple times as tears ran down his face.

Even though he was scared, his cock was still pretty hard. “Look, seems like he’s enjoying this after all…” I said as I wiggled his cock. Chase laughed as I opened my mouth and stuck my tongue out. He might have been a jerk, but that guy was hot as fuck. Lean abs, plump pecs, large shoulders, thick thighs, smooth skin and a face to melt an iceberg. I was over excited to have him all for me and Chase. I stopped at his purplish cock head, lick it and made out with it. “Come on, show him what a good cocksucker you are…” Chase said as held onto Spencer’s hair and shoved his cock deeper. I smiled as I engulfed the 9’ inches shaft in my mouth. He moaned despite him, as I took it all the way in. His plump cock head rubbing my throat felt like heaven. I began bobbing my head up and down along his shaft. I pulled my cock out of the pouch of my jock and started jacking off as I sucked on his cock. I looked up at him, his throat flexed as Chase fucked his face. “You certainly can take a cock pretty well for straight guy… we’re gonna have you begging for more by the end of the night…” Chase said as he thrusted his cock back and forth.

I was having such a blast. The way his throat expanded and flexed as Chase fucked his face was so hot. I feasted Spencer’s delicious cock. His low hanging balls were so satisfying to play with. I occasionally sucked on them, letting them pop in and out one after the other. He was producing quite a fair amount of precum. “Damn look at all that precum…” I said as I smeared it along his shaft before lapping on it. I could hear his moans muffled by Chase’s cock. I started rubbing his hole with my fingers as I sucked his cock. I could feel him clenching it, but I licked my fingers and forced them in. “Arrghhmmmpphhh arggllluughh” His moaning made him gag on Chase’s cock, a tear ran down his cheek. I started twisting my finger, rubbing his prostate. His cock twitched and bounced up. I shoved it back in my mouth as I inserted a second finger in his ass. His body tensed as I stretched him open, but soon I felt him relax. That’s when I started thrusting my fingers back and forth. His cock was now raging hard.

“I think it’s time to use something bigger…” I said as I stood up. “We should tie him to his bed so I could work his ass better” I added as Chase pulled his cock out of Spencer’s mouth. He grabbed a rope and helped me while I took the handcuffs off. He tried to escape, but Chase and I were holding him with a firm grip. “You’re not going anywhere little slut! We’re gonna fuck you so hard…” I said as we forced him face down on the bed. I got on top of him while Chase tied his wrist to the bed post. He then tied his ankles, that way his legs were spread open, giving us full access to his straight man pussy. He had a perfect round bubble butt, lightly haired, but still smooth. I massaged his ass then spread his cheeks appart to see his beautiful pink hole. “Don’t you dare stick your dick in my ass faggot!” Spencer blurted when Chase have me the lube. I slapped his ass real hard, leaving an imprint on it. “Shut up! This is your last warning, if you keep disrespecting us, we’re gonna beat the hell out of you, Am. I. Clear?!” I said as I gripped his hair and pulled his head up. “Yes sir… ” He replied angrily. I let got of his hair and poured some lube on my cock and smeared some on his hole. Chase got beside me and spread Spencer’s ass for me.

I rubbed my cock over his hole, gently applying pressure. Spencer started breathing faster as he got nervous. He knew there was no escaping, he was going to get fucked. I pushed my cock on his hole until it popped in. “Aaaahhh arrrghhh uuughhh mmmmpphhh….” He whimpered as I slowly stuffed it all in. “There you go… I knew you were a bottom bitch after all” Chase said as he tapped his ass. ”You’re gonna pay for this assholes!” Spencer yelled as he tried to free himself again. I just laughed and slammed my cock real hard in his ass. “Arrggh uh huh uhhh I’m sorry! I’m sorry stop!” He begged as his body tensed. “Yea that’s it, apologize to your masters slut!” I said as slammed my cock all the way inside him a few more times. His whole body twitched and flexed as he squealed painfully. “Aaaaaarrghhh uughhh ggghhuhhh pleease….  st stop… pleasee” He said almost crying as his buns bounced in sync with my thrusting. “Already? We’re just getting started…” I whispered in his ear as I leaned on him.

At this moment I understood why Chase was doing stuff like that. This feeling of power, having control over such a hot cocky stud. It was overwhelmingly hot. Having this straight guy begged for mercy. I kept thrusting my shaft in his hole. Poor guy he couldn’t do anything… He wouldn’t stop whimpering and begging me to stop. Chase turned his head sideways and stuffed his cock in his mouth. “Shhhhhssh enough now, just relax and accept the fact that you’re our bitch now big boy…” He said Spencer gagged on his cock. Chase and I looked at each other smiling. We high-fived as we laughed and railed him by both ends. His hole gradually relaxed and I felt him release the tension in his body. He stopped gagging and was actually taking Chase’s cock all the way in. His groans of pain slowly turned into pleasure moans. Chase pulled out and let him get some air. “How do you like it now boy?” Chase asked as he caressed his face with his cock. “I love it sir… I want more please…” Spencer begged with a resigned slutty voice. He opened his mouth and stuck out tongue.

“Haha that’s a good boy…” Chase replied as he shoved his cock back in his mouth. I was now fucking him at full intensity and seemed to be enjoying this. “Mmmmphhh fuck yea… fuck my ass sir!” He moaned as he took his breath. The fact that this tough straight guy was now reduce to be our fuck toy was exhilarating. “Yea? You like having that big fucking cock up your ass huh?” I said as I railed him and slapped his ass. “Uggghh yeaa fuck me sir!! Fuck me hard!” He replied as he clenched his hole. We were so focused on plowing him, it was as if there was nothing else in the world. So much we didn’t hear the front door open. “Spencer?! You forgot your wallet at the bar!” We heard a guy yell. Chase quickly shut Spencer’s mouth with his cock while I got to the bedroom door. “Spencer?” We heard along with footsteps coming towards us. The door finally opened. “WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON HERE?!!” He blurted as he jumped. I quickly tackled him and grabbed the cuffs that were on the floor. “GET THE FUCK OFF ME!! SPENCER!!!” I shut him up by putting a pair of boxers that were on the floor in his mouth.

“What do we do now?” I asked as I looked at Chase. “Well… I guess now we have two toys to play with…”