Toying Around

Garrett's Revenge

AUTHORS NOTE: Hi guys! Thank you so much for your support in the first part of 'Toying Around'. Hope you guys enjoy this second part, and as always, any feedback is appreciated! I would love to continue this story further, but I am beginning to suffer from some writer's block, so feel free to comment or e-mail me some things you want to see in future entries! Thank you!

---

It had been several months since Garrett had been introduced to the wonderful world of ass play by his semi-psychotic fraternity president, Luke. Following the day that Garrett was relentlessly tortured by Luke with a remote-controlled vibrator, conversation between the two had grown sparse. This was mostly due to their desire to keep their encounter a secret from the rest of the fraternity. 

Sigma Chi Epsilon had a reputation around campus for being home to several homophobic “brothers”. If these brothers found out that their president willingly engaged in a sexual encounter with a man, Luke could forget his position in the social hierarchy. He would be instantly shunned and outcast by his peers, a fate that he vehemently didn’t want, and would do anything to avoid. 

But having to see Garrett in the house every single day was a temptation that Luke was struggling to resist. In the months following their encounter, Garrett had only gotten sexier. His muscles had gotten bigger, his confidence had gotten stronger, and that gorgeous bubble butt of his was looking better than ever. 

Garrett never intentionally dressed immodestly, but given his build, it was impossible for him to find an outfit that didn’t show off his ass, legs, upper body, and bulge in a ridiculously sexy manner. Luke found himself swooning at the sight of Garrett in nearly anything he wore: gray sweatpants, hoodies, pajama bottoms, shorts. You name it, Garrett looked good in it. 

But one day, Luke couldn’t resist anymore. 

As money was beginning to grow tight for Luke, he cancelled his membership at his favorite gym in exchange for a much cheaper membership at the gym on-campus. It was an alternative that he wasn’t particularly fond of, but with graduation coming soon and the looming future student-loan debt, Luke knew it was time to start saving money. 

What Luke didn’t know was that Garrett went to this gym too. 

The gym was packed. Luke was sat at the lateral pulldown machine, pulling an impressive 215 pounds from above his head down to his waist. His black stringer barely covered his upper body, exposing the majority of his impressive build to voyeuristic onlookers. Although the intended purpose of the shirt wasn’t attention, Luke didn’t mind it.  

After finishing a set of 12, Luke stood up off the bench and began his 60 second rest before beginning his next set. With his hands on his hips, Luke began surveying the other gymgoers. That’s when he spotted Garrett at a squat rack, and Luke instantly felt his heart skip a beat. 

The outfit that Garrett was wearing was marvelous. He wore a wifebeater t-shirt that wrapped his upper body like a Christmas present. His perky nipples and 6-pack abs rubbed against the front, while his muscular back flexed in the back. His lower back was being covered by the tightest pair of gray Adidas shorts Luke had ever seen in his life. Garrett’s ass was pressed so tightly against the fabric that it was genuinely amazing they weren't bursting at the seams. 

Luke watched as Garrett loaded 350 pounds onto the bar, placed the bar on his shoulders, and began his routine. It was clear that Garrett had already been doing this for a while, as there was a large sweat stain between Garrett’s cheeks that was only visible when he reached the very bottom of his squat. When he pulled himself back up to the top, the sweat stain disappeared between his ass.  

Luke marveled as every muscle in Garrett’s sexy, hairy legs flexed as he performed his set. His legs had only gotten bigger and better since the day of the vibrator. His quads had easily doubled in size, his hamstrings became significantly more prominent, and his calf’s barely looked real. As if he wasn’t sexy enough before, Garrett now looked like a Michaelangelo sculpture come to life. 

When Garrett finished his set, he set the bar back on the squat rack, turned around, and made direct eye contact with Luke. Luke felt his stomach drop. Did Garrett know he was watching him? Garrett flashed his pearly-white smile in Luke’s direction, which calmed his nerves slightly. Against his better judgement, Luke approached him. 

“I didn’t know you worked out here.” Luke said with a grin. 

“Me? I’ve been going here for months, and this is the first time I’ve ever seen you here!” Garrett responded. “I thought you used to go to that fancy-ass bodybuilding gym that was a few blocks over.” 

“Yeah, I used to. I cancelled my membership because it got to be too expensive.” Luke explained. 

Garrett smiled, “Oh yeah? Need to borrow some money?” 

Luke laughed in response and playfully punched Garrett in his vascular arm. “Wow, your arms are sick, bro.” Luke said, squeezing Garrett’s bicep. 

“Thanks, man. I’ve been working harder than ever before.” Garrett responded. 

“It shows.” Luke smiled. 

“So, it’s been months since me and you have last talked. What makes you suddenly decide to come up to me now?” Garrett inquired. “You trying to make me have another seizure in the middle of a bar?” 

Luke laughed. “I don’t know. I just saw you from the pulldown machine and couldn’t help but notice how great you look in those shorts.” 

Both boys could tell the direction that this conversation was going, but they knew that this wasn’t the place for it. They were surrounded in all directions by testosterone-ridden alpha male maniacs who would beat them to a pulp if anything even remotely gay occurred. With a slight smile, Garrett picked his gym bag and water bottle up off the floor. 

“I’m heading out now, that set I just did was my last one. How much longer have you got?” Garrett asked. 

“I just finished, too.” Luke lied. 

“Then let’s head out.” Garrett said, moving towards the exit. Luke quickly followed. 

The boys walked side-by-side back to their fraternity house. The sexual tension was thick enough to be cut with a knife, but they did their best to refrain from doing anything in the middle of the sidewalk.  

“I think about what you did to me with that vibrator almost every day.” Garrett said. 

“Really?” Luke said, shocked. 

“Bro, it actually changed my life. I’ve spent every day since then trying to recreate the pleasure that vibrator gave me.” Garrett said with great enthusiasm. 

“Has anything worked?” Luke asked. 

“Nope. My fingers felt pretty good, but not even half as good as that damn vibrator did.” Garret smiled. 

At this point, the boys were now walking up the steps to their frat house. They cut the conversation short to avoid any of their brothers hearing it. The two acted as casually as they could as they walked through the front doors and maneuvered their way through the house. After what felt like an eternity, they finally reached their destination: Luke’s room. 

Luke shut and locked the door behind him. To his surprise, Garrett didn’t immediately pounce on him. “Is it a good idea for us to be doing this right now? The house is packed.” Garrett said nervously. 

“So, you were fine with forcing you to lose your shit in the middle of a bar, but now you're concerned?” Luke said, genuinely curious. 

“Everyone who was at the bar thinks I just had some sort of medical emergency, like a seizure or a spasm. Nobody knows the truth.” Garrett answered. 

Luke walked over to his drawer and retrieved the infamous vibrator. He held it out towards Garrett. “Think you can keep quiet?” Luke asked. Garrett immediately shook his head “no”. There was absolutely no way. 

But then, a devious smile spread across Garrett’s face. “What about you?” Garrett asked. 

“NO! This thing doesn’t go inside of me. Sorry.” Luke defended. 

“Then why do you own it?” Garrett asked. 

“It was a gag gift. Connor bought it for me for my birthday as a joke. I don’t even know why I kept it.” Luke explained. 

Garrett was shocked. “Wait, so you’ve never put that thing up your own ass before?” 

“Nope.” Luke said with a shrug. 

In one quick swipe, Garrett stole the vibrator right from Luke’s hand. “Why don’t we change that?” Garrett asked. 

“Nope. Not a chance in hell. Pigs will fly before I allow you to put that thing inside of my ass.” Luke said, slightly angered. 

Garrett moved closer to Luke, now standing merely an inch away from his face. “So, you’re saying no?” 

“That’s exactly what I’m saying”. Luke said. 

“How come I wasn’t able to say ‘no’, but you can?” Garrett said, his voice too beginning to tremble with anger. 

“Come on. Chill out, bro.” Luke said. 

“You know, I may be shorter than you, but I’m a lot stronger than you are now.” Garrett said, his anger beginning to grow. “This vibrator is going in one way or another.” 

Luke let out a nervous chuckle. He knew that karma was coming back to bite him now. He knew that Garrett was stronger than him, and there was no way he would be able to overpower him anymore.  

“Put your hands on the door and spread your legs.” Garrett commanded. 

“Not going to happen.” Luke said, trying to maintain his dominance. 

“Don’t be difficult.” Garrett hissed. “Hands on the door.” 

Luke wanted to stand his ground but knew that this was a battle he was going to lose sooner or later. Defeated, he walked over to his bedroom door, placed his hands against it, and spread his legs, just as he was instructed. 

Garrett approached Luke from behind and began breathing down his neck. Garrett began fondling Luke’s muscular ass through his shorts. Luke’s ass, while still impressive, was much more muscular than Garrett’s. Luke never worked out his glutes, as he never wanted any attention to be brought to his ass. However, his glutes were currently receiving more attention than they ever had before. 

In one swift motion, Garrett yanked Luke’s shorts to the ground. For the first time ever, Garrett marveled at the sight of Luke’s ass, which was still encased inside of his gray boxer-briefs. His cheeks were muscular and plump, and stuck out much further than the small of his back. Garrett began massaging Luke’s ass through the material. 

“You ever been rimmed before?” Garrett whispered. 

“No.” Luke responded quickly. 

“Then let’s change that.” Garrett smiled, beginning to bend to his knees. 

Garrett was now face-to-face with Luke’s ass. Garrett pressed his face between Luke’s still-clothed ass, deeply inhaling his scent. It was a glorious, musky smell that was a direct result of Luke’s workout. Garrett slowly lowered Luke’s underwear, revealing Luke’s ass to the light. Garrett admired the sight of Luke’s ass: it’s paleness compared to the rest of Luke’s body, how it was slightly hairy, and its definition. 

Garrett spread Luke’s cheeks, exposing Luke’s tight asshole that was hidden behind a good amount of hair. Garrett then launched himself in and began attacking the tiny muscle with his tongue. 

Luke let out a loud and abrupt gasp as his most sacred and secretive region was bombarded by Garrett’s warm, wet tongue. Luke clasped his hand over his mouth to try and stifle the moans erupting from his throat. 

“Holy fuuuuuuck!” Luke exclaimed in response to the unfamiliar sensation. 

Garrett took great pleasure in pleasing his frenemy. Although he was incredibly inexperienced in eating ass, he listened to Luke’s noises and watched his movements to find out what felt best. The smell and taste of Luke’s sweaty, hairy ass was enough to make Garrett feel goosebumps. He ran his hands up and down Luke’s thick, muscular legs as he gave him the rimming of a lifetime. 

Luke could feel a weakness growing in his knees as Garrett drove him to levels of pleasure he didn’t know existed. As Garrett lapped and salivated all over his puckering hole, he could feel his dick growing erect and his head spinning. His eyes rolled deep into the back of his head as a dribble of drool escaped his moaning mouth and splattered on the floor. 

“D- Dude, holy FUCK, that feels so fuuucking gooood.” Luke moaned, glancing over his shoulder at Garrett. 

“Yeah? How about this?” Garrett said as he spread Luke’s cheeks far apart and shoved his slender tongue directly into Luke’s asshole. Luke responded by banging his fist into the door and screaming “FUCK!” 

Deep, guttural moans continued rushing from Luke as the ass eating continued. Garrett was now fully fucking Luke with his tongue, and Luke was loving every single second of it. He moaned loud and proud, without a single care in the world. Or so he thought, because the boy's session was suddenly interrupted by a knock on the door. 

“Hey, Luke? Are you in there.” the voice on the other side of the door inquired. 

Luke quickly pushed Garrett’s head out from between his ass. “Dude, stop! I think that’s Connor.” Luke said in a frightened, hushed tone. 

“Then answer the door.” Garrett said as he returned his tongue to Luke’s ass. 

“I- I caaan’t. Not with you eeeaatinggg me ouuuuut.” Luke gasped shakily between his moans. 

“You’re the fraternity president, Luke. You must answer the door. What kind of president doesn’t answer the door for a brother in need?” Garrett said. 

Luke kicked Garrett in the leg, knocking him back to the floor. “Listen to me,” Luke commanded, “I am the fraternity president, you’re damn right about that. Stop eating me out now, or you’re out of the house next year. Understand?” 

“Fine.” Garrett shrugged. 

Connor knocked again. “Luke, can you open the door, please?” 

Luke quickly pulled his shorts back up and opened the door enough to only poke his head out. Sure enough, Connor stood on the other side holding a large bong in his hands. 

“Can we use this?” Connor asked. 

“For what?” Luke responded. 

“Oh, you know, to play golf with.” Connor said sarcastically. “No, we want to smoke, duh!” 

“No! Are you fucking crazy?” Luke scolded. “If campus finds out we are done for. They’ll shut our whole chapter down.” 

Luke and Connor continued bickering back and forth. Unbeknownst to both men, Garrett was quietly scooting across the floor with the vibrator in his hands. Once close enough, Garrett began fondling Luke’s ass through his shorts once again. Luke jolted slightly, and Connor noticed. 

“You good, bro?” Connor asked, concerned. 

“Yeah, I’m fine.” Luke shot back. 

Garrett was now lowering the back of Luke’s shorts, revealing his ass yet again. With the vibrator in hand, Garret began teasingly rubbing it up and down Luke’s crack. Luke could feel an anxious sweat forming on his brow. 

“You don’t look so fine. Everything okay?” Connor asked 

“I’m fine!” Luke said, agitated. 

Without warning, Garrett began inserting the vibrator into Luke’s virgin hole. Luke did everything in his power to try and hide what was going on, but he wasn’t doing a very good job at it. His face contorted and twisted, and subtle moans began working his way from his sealed lips. “Dude, what is wrong?” Connor asked. 

“Oh my God!” Luke said as the toy pressed up right against his prostate. It wasn’t even vibrating, yet it still felt beyond amazing. Garret continued teasing Luke by intentionally rubbing the toy back and forth, right against Luke’s g-spot. Luke could feel sweat pooling down his face, and his legs beginning to shake. 

“Okay, whatever. Also, did you ever talk to Jake about the party next week?” Connor asked. 

Luke wanted nothing more than for this conversation to be over. He knew that Garrett was about to switch the toy on at any given moment and didn’t want Connor to be there for it. If it felt this good while turned off, how was it going to feel turned on? 

“I- I’ll t- t- taaalk to him ne- next week.” Luke said, beginning to feel overwhelmed by the intense pleasure radiating from his backdoor. 

“Okay. Oh also-” Connor began.  

“Bye!” Luke said, abruptly slamming the door in Connor’s face. 

Luke swiftly turned around and, in a moment of pure anger, punched Garrett directly in the face. Garrett fell backwards, hitting the floor hard. 

“Fuck you! What the fuck is your issue?” Luke screamed. 

“My issue? I’m doing the exact same thing to you that you did to me!” Garrett yelled back. 

“Yeah, but it's different. I’m the fraternity president! I have an image to maintain, Garrett. I can’t be fucking moaning in front of these guys!” Luke responded. 

Garrett got up off the floor, his face growing red with anger. Luke began to cower. He shouldn’t have punched Garrett. Now, Garrett was walking over to him with a look in his face that he had never seen before: a look of pure, unbridled rage. 

Garrett grabbed Luke around the waist and flipped him over his shoulder as if he weighed nothing. Garrett marched over to the bed and aggressively whipped Luke onto it. Before Luke could even begin to move, Garrett pinned him down with his knees, and began fishing through Luke’s bedside drawer for the same restraints Luke had previously used on him. It didn’t take long. Garrett found them and began tying Luke down to the bed. 

“Listen, Garrett. I’m sorry. Please don’t do whatever it is you’re about to do!” Luke pleaded. 

Garrett was blinded by his rage. Luke’s words were simply traveling in one ear and out the other. Garrett had no intention on Listening to Luke’s pleas. He was 100% focused on making sure Luke was adequately restrained. By the time he was done, Luke was unable to move. Garrett had tied him to the bed much tighter than Luke had done to him. 

“This was going to be about your pleasure, but not anymore. Now, this is about revenge. You made a fool of me in front of everyone at the bar and the store. So now, I’m going to make a fool out of you.” Garrett whispered tauntingly. 

Luke desperately attempted to break free from his restraints but was fully unable to move. “Please, Garrett, please!” Luke begged. “I’m sorry, I’m so sorry. Let me go, please!” 

“No.” Garrett said flatly. 

With that, Garrett pulled out his phone. Luke continued fidgeting anxiously on the bed as Garrett began downloading the app to control the vibrator. Luke knew he wasn’t going to be able to control himself. He knew that he was going to lose control, and the guys inside the house were going to find him like this. He tried so hard to break free from his restraints, but he just couldn’t do it. 

After a few minutes of silence, Garrett flipped his phone screen towards Luke, revealing that the app had finished downloading. “Garrett, please. I beg. Don’t!” Luke pleaded. But his words held no merit for Garrett. With a smile on his face, Garrett brought the toy to level one. 

The pleasure was immediate and intense. The anticipation of the situation caused Luke to scream loudly out of shock when the toy began to buzz against his prostate. His hips shot up for a moment, and then he shakily returned them to the bed. His cock instantly began to involuntarily grow, but aside from that, he remained calm. 

Garrett enjoyed the sight of his muscular fraternity president being purely at his mercy. There’s something so exhilarating about seeing a gorgeous, young, muscular, masculine man being tied down and fully humiliated. 

“Let’s get rid of the rest of your clothes, what do you say?” Garrett said, gripping Luke’s stringer by the collar. In the same way that Luke had once done to him, Garrett ripped the stringer directly off of Luke’s chest. Luke wanted to cuss him out, but was too distracted by the pleasure to say anything. 

Garrett began running his hand over Luke’s chiseled chest. “Don’t worry, I know how it feels. I was in your shoes, too.” 

“Is there anything I can do to make you stop?” Luke asked. 

“Nope!” Garrett proclaimed with a chuckle. With that, he brought the toy up to level two. 

Luke began moaning softly, and he could feel his hips beginning to rise. The pleasure flowed through him like electricity. He hated how good it felt. To make matters worse, Garrett was now stroking Luke’s erect cock. 

“No! No! Don’t do that! Please.” Luke pleaded. 

“You don’t tell me what to do.” Garrett hissed. 

“Oh, fuck off!” Luke hissed out of anger. Big mistake. 

“Oh, that’s it.” Garrett said. Without any warning, Garrett switched the toy to its highest level: level ten. 

Luke could feel his earth shatter around him as indescribable, unrelenting pleasure began to wash over him. Almost instantly, his legs and upper body began to shake involuntarily. His eyes rolled back in his head, drool ran from his mouth like a faucet, and animalistic moans began rushing from his gaping jaw. 

It was truly a sight to see. Goosebumps ran over Luke’s red skin as the pleasure grew inside of him. Garrett was no longer touching his cock, but he could still feel a tremendous pressure building inside of him. Luke was fully screaming now. He was shaking and convulsing violently. Every vein in his body pressed against his skin as Luke fought hard to break free from the restraints that were holding him down. 

Then, someone began knocking at the door. “Dude? Are you okay” the voice asked. It was Connor. 

Garrett smiled deviously at Luke. Luke began shaking his head “no”, but Garrett had no intention of listening. “Come in!” Garrett yelled. Moments later, Connor did. 

Upon enter, Connot was immediately greeted with the sight of his nude fraternity president with a vibrator shoved up his ass. Luke was still moaning loudly and shaking violently. Pre-cum was now flowing out of his erect dick and landing in the trimmed pubes that sat just above it. Connor watched, amazed. 

“What do you think?” Garrett asked. 

“I don’t even know what’s happening.” Connor admitted. 

“Shut the door and come here.” Garrett commanded. 

Garrett watched as Connor obliged. Connor was another one of the fraternity’s exceptionally handsome brothers. He was of average height, no more than 5’11”, and had a gorgeous, athletic build. He wasn’t as big as Luke or Garrett, but he was still exceptionally attractive. He kept his body in tip-top shape, but still valued athleticism and health over aesthetics and size. 

Connor walked over and watched as Luke continued to scream and writhe on the bed. Luke was an absolute mess. His body was completely covered in his own sweat, pre-cum, and drool. He was as red as a lobster, and genuinely looked as if he was possessed by a demon. Shockingly, Connor seemed to enjoy the spectacle. 

“What’s happening to him?” Connor asked, genuinely confused. 

“See that thing in his butt?” Garrett asked, pointing to the vibrator. “It’s vibrating. In case you can’t tell, Luke likes it a lot.” 

“I’ll say.” Connor said, chuckling. “Feel good, Luke?” 

Luke was barely aware of his surroundings. His body was so incredibly overwhelmed and overstimulated that he couldn’t focus on anything but the pleasure. He could feel a pressure continuing to grow inside of his dick. Fearing the worst, he gained his composure enough to speak. 

“GARRETT. ST – ST- STOOOOP.” Luke pleaded. 

“Why should I?” Garrett laughed. 

“I- I’M GONNA- I'M GONNAAAAAA-” Luke began screeching. 

Garrett and Connor watched in amazement as thick, creamy cum began shooting out of Luke’s cock without him even needing to touch it. The cum shot high in the air, splattering on the ceiling and the wall behind him. 

It seemed as if it was never going to stop. For almost 30 consecutive seconds, Luke screamed and groaned as shot after shot of cum spurted from his dick. Garrett and Connor watched in amazement as Luke’s orgasm continued to last long after he finished cumming. 

“Should we turn the toy off?” Connor asked, noticing that it was still forcing Luke to spasm and scream on the bed. 

“Yeah, I guess.” Garrett responded. Garrett gripped the end of the toy and yanked it out of Luke’s ass. Luke let out a loud sigh, grateful that the torture was finally over. It was only at that moment that Luke caught sight of Connor. 

“Connor?!” Luke exclaimed, horrified. “What are you doing here?” 

“Enjoying the show.” Connor said, smiling. 

“Did you let him in?” Luke said to Garrett. 

“Duh.” Garrett said. 

Luke pulled himself up slightly. “Listen here, dickweeds. If you tell anyone about this, you’re both out of the house. Understand?” 

Both boys nodded in agreement. 

Garrett playfully elbowed Connor. “So, what did you think?” Garrett asked. 

“It was hot.” Connor smiled. “I never knew you were so ripped, Luke.” Connor elaborated, running his hands over Luke’s sweaty body. 

Garrett began removing Luke’s restraints. Once done, Luke rubbed the marks on his arms and legs where the rope had been. The skin was bright red and burning, a cruel reminder of what he had just endured. 

“So, are we even now?” Luke asked. 

“I guess.” Garrett chuckled. All was well between the boys again. 

Luke then turned to Connor. “Hey, want to give us a little alone time?” 

“Sure.” Connor said. He headed for the door, but turned back just as he was about to leave. “Next time you guys do this freaky shit, invite me along.” With a wink, Connor headed out. Now alone, Luke and Garrett stared at each other. 

“What do we need alone time for? We’re even now.” Garrett inquired. 

Without a word, Luke leapt forward and began kissing Garrett on his lips. Garrett wrapped his arms around Luke and began returning the love. Before they knew it, both boys were sprawled on the bed, aggressively making out with each other. 

After a few minutes, Garrett pulled himself away. “Everything okay?” Luke asked. 

“I want you to fuck me.” Garrett responded. 

“What?” Luke said, shocked. 

“Did I stutter? I said FUCK ME!” Garrett exclaimed, bending himself doggy-style in front of Luke. 

TO BE CONTINUED