Police Interview

Transcript of Interview of Keith Butler, 4 JAN 2021

Officer Kousik

So, I understand that, um, the first time you met John Garcin was in your father’s office at the construction site at 3800 Elm Drive on the 22nd of December.

Keith Butler

No, that wasn’t the first time.  I’d met him briefly a week before when my father introduced me to the crew.  But I saw him about six months before, actually it was in May, after my last final exam.

Officer Kousik

Tell me about that and anything you remember about the encounter.  Try to give me any details you remember.  Everything.  Don’t leave anything out.  It may not seem important now, but it may help me later.

Keith Butler

(audible sigh)  You want to know everything?  Fuck.  OK then.  Well, on the last day of school, after my last final, intro to psych, I was supposed to go to my friend Lynn’s house after school.  That’s Lyndell Johnson.  But he had his plans change, his mother wanted to take him somewhere, so he canceled on me.  Anyway, I went home instead, and when I got to the hall with the bedrooms, I heard some noises.  I could tell they were sex noises, and I knew it wasn’t my sister and her boyfriend because both the voices were guys.

My dick got hard, you know, I’m gay, and it sounded like porn.  I had to go take a peek.  As I got closer, I was sure it was my dad and someone else, and I was interested, because when I came out to my dad, he was very supportive.  Hearing him with another guy would mean he was gay, too.  So I wanted to take a look.

I guess I also wanted to know if it was Steve Harper from next door because he’s really hot.  I know he’s my dad’s age, but I’d always had fantasies about him.  From when I was twelve and started to realize I liked guys.  Anyway, I tiptoed to the doorway, and I saw John.  He was riding my dad’s dick.  I’d never seen my dad with an erection before, and John had one, too, and it was bouncing on my dad’s stomach.  The image is burned into my mind.  They were doing it like in the videos I’ve seen.

I snuck into my room and jerked off, and I kept imagining what it would be like to fuck John, so you can imagine when I was introduced to him, I wondered, you know, if I could do him.  He’s good looking and has a nice body.  I tried to hold his hand while we shook hands just a little longer than I did with the other guys.  Plus, I looked him straight in the eyes.  I remember that he smiled and nodded at me, but so did some of the other guys.

So, um, I was mostly working in the office, trying to organize files.  My dad just makes piles of shit and then tosses them in boxes.  It was a nightmare.  I started to make some headway when my dad came in to say he needed to get something from Frank’s.  That’s a supply store about thirty miles from the office, and he wanted me to go along.  I didn’t want to because I was finally getting somewhere.

You know, this is kind of embarrassing.  I don’t see how it’s going to help.

Officer Kousik

Sometimes it’s difficult for individuals to see the big picture in an investigation.  Believe me, this helps me.  Don’t leave out any details.

Officer Kousik

OK.  So, as I was sorting and shredding papers, John came into the office.  He’s in one of those one-piece work suits that zips up the front.  Only his is unzipped all the way to the crotch.  He tells me that he’s there to work on the photo wall.  A new one is supposed to come in and he needs to make room for it.  He pulls one of the pictures from the wall, and tells me that it’ll be like that one.  He came really close to me and asked me if it was OK.  He said he wanted to make sure that he wasn’t bothering me.

To be honest, he was bothering me.  A lot.  I could see his smooth chest and he had washboard abs.  I could even see his pubic hair.

My dick was getting hard, and I thought fuck it; go for it.  My dad was on his way out of town, and John was coming on to me  I reached my hand over and slid it under his clothes and rubbed his nipple with my finger.  He turned and looked at me.

“Fuck, that feels nice,” he said.  “What else are you going to do?”

I remembered a line from this porn I’d watched, so I said, “You want me to tell you, or you want it to be a surprise?”

Officer Kousik

[inaudible]

Keith Butler

What?

Officer Kousik

Continue, please.

Keith Butler

So he said, “Surprise me.”  I’d been practicing kissing with Lyndell, so I pushed my lips against John’s lips and I ran my tongue across his mouth.  He dropped the painting and grabbed me by the ears and kissed me really hard.  It scared me a little.  Then I felt his pecker push against me.  I reached down and rubbed my hand against his abs and then grabbed his cock.  He gasped.  I think that because I knew he’d been with my father, I was a little more aggressive than I would have been normally.

“That’s one hairy bush,” I told him.  “Is your ass hairy, too?  I love fucking a hairy hole.”

Then he said, “Who says you’re going to fuck me?” 

“I do.  We’re going to take turns.”

He grabbed me and kissed me again.  “You whore.”

I pushed him back on the couch.  “I’m no whore, but I’m working on being a slut.”  I put my knee between his legs and pushed just a little.  “You going to help me with that?”  I’m not sure why, but I felt really cocky.  I knew my dad wouldn’t fire someone he’d been fucking, but I felt as though I had some power.  I stood up and told him to get naked.

John took off his shoes and his uniform, and he was nude, you know.  He wasn’t wearing anything under the uniform.  He had a nice dick.  I’ve seen a few in person, and his was nice. It had to be seven inches of perfect cylinder.  The foreskin just touched the tip.  His balls were huge and hung down between his legs farther than I had ever seen.  I got on my knees and tried to get the whole thing in my mouth.  It didn’t work, but I kept trying and finally felt him pop into my throat and my nose was in his pubic hair.  It was exciting because he kept saying, “Fuck, that’s great.  That’s so good.  Yeah, keep doing it.”  He finally stopped me because he said he was getting close and he wanted to drop his load in my ass.

He pushed me on the couch and started sucking me.  I’ve been sucked a few times.  Once from a friend at a costume party dressed up like a cop [laughs], but John was good.  I shouted a few times, and I was worried someone might come in and find us.  He was strong, too, because he went from sucking me to licking my butt.  He was holding me down, and it was awesome.  He worked at getting me wet and started to finger fuck my ass.

I know that I looked at him and said, “Stop teasing me and stick your dick in me.”  He had this grin on his face.  He stuck his dick in me, and while he was fucking me, he said, “I wish your daddy could see this.”  He pushed open the curtains and looked out, and then he said, “Too bad, your daddy still ain’t here.”

I wondered whether he really wanted my father to join us, you know, from the way he kept looking out the window and saying “Oh, is that him?”.  I’m not into that shit.  Watching my dad fuck someone was one thing, and I didn’t hang around long for that one, but I’m not into incest or partnering up with him to fuck a dude.

John said he was getting close, but he didn’t want to come yet.  He climbed on top of my dick, and started riding me.  I wanted to fuck him while he was on his back, but he wouldn’t let me.  He just kept looking out the window and hollering, “Come on, Daddy.”

When I came inside him, he just kept fucking my dick, probably for another two minutes before he closed the curtain.  I remember that because my dick was starting to hurt.  You know how it is when you’ve come, how it gets super sensitive.

Officer Kousik

[inaudible]

Keith Butler

Then he stood over me and jerked off.

I wanted to cuddle just a little, but he threw his clothes on and headed out.  He was gone about, oh, less than five minutes, when he ran back in and said it was gone.

Officer Kousik

So, while you and John were fucking in the office, the Bobcat was stolen?

Keith Butler

Yeah, it was gone when John went out.  Neither of us heard anything.  John came back and told me it had been moved, truck, trailer, and Bobcat.  I called the police.  My dad said he would have taken a look around before calling,  you know, done more searching, but since it never turned up, he was glad I called.

Officer Kousik

I see.

Keith Butler

After I called the police, John went back out.  I saw him at the edge of the parking lot.  He was smoking a cigarette.  I didn’t know he smoked; I’d never seen him do it before.  I don’t like it.

Officer Kousik

Some people are addicted.

Keith Butler

Yeah, but I don’t like it.  It stinks and it’s poison.  He was still doing it when the police showed up.  They asked me some questions, but I didn’t know anything about the equipment, so I wasn’t any help.

Officer Kousik

Have you talked to John since then?  I mean, about anything.  Are you still having sex with him.

Keith Butler

No.  It was just that once.  I don’t date smokers.  Do you smoke?

Officer Kousik

No.  I don’t.  I think that concludes the interview.  I will call you if I need you to go over anything else.

Keith Butler

What do you think is going on?

Officer Kousik

I’m sorry Keith; I can’t disclose anything until the investigation is over.  You’re free to go.

Keith Butler

Would you go out with me?  You’re cute, and…

Officer Kousik

I can’t Keith.  My wife doesn’t like it when I date cute young guys.

Keith Butler

Oh.  Sorry.  [sounds of door opening and closing, papers shuffling]

Officer Savage

Shit, Kousik.  That was hot.

Officer Kousik

It was just two guys fucking.  Get over it.

Officer Savage

I noticed you were tugging at your pole.  And when the dude asked you out.

Officer Kousik

You saw me adjusting myself, that’s all.

Officer Savage

Bullshit.  I’m not sure which got me harder.  The story or your reaction.  And when you lied to him about having a wife.

Officer Kousik

Fuck you, Savage.

Officer Savage

Exactly.  I think I’ll go home and shower.  And wait for you.  Don’t forget to bring your dick.

Officer Kousik

Not yet.  We need to get a warrant to arrest John.  He was involved.  Then I’ll fuck you to celebrate.

--END of TRANSCRIPT--