Gary's Choice

“You’re a grandfather” wrote Hunter in an email. “Leo was born last week.” There was a picture of Nick with his arm around Timothy who was holding a cute baby boy. They were sitting on a bench in a backyard. “I’ve copied Timothy’s message for you. It’s quite a story:”

Nick and I were nude, stroking each other’s hard dicks and fondling each other’s heavy balls. We were standing before a bed in our house on which lay the naked Lynette. She was 26, had long blonde hair, blue eyes, a trim athletic physique and naturally full breasts. She was a beautiful woman with alluring and expressive facial features.

I watched my husband get on top of her. Lynette gasped and sighed as Nick’s big dick penetrated her blonde pussy. Nick’s hips aggressively pummeled against her and his dick thrust in and out of her, their bodies slapping against each other’s. Nick’s silent fucking went on for a few minutes until he howled when he came. He pulled out, got up, his beautiful cock that I know so well was now soft and dangling. He stood near the bed.

In a split second I sped to the bed and got on top of Lynette. OH MY FUCKING GOD! Oh, the sensations I felt as my raging dick parted the silky taut lips of her pussy, moist with my husband’s cum and her own juices. I could have passed out from the ecstasy of my dick going fully in to her, experiencing her fantastic tightness. I remembered what this felt like and the man I once was.

I had been straight and fucked my ex-girlfriend several times. For the last two years I had been a passive sex object for hire, catering to so many men in so many often demented ways. The spine-tingling pleasure I now was feeling was profound and complex.

It had been a long time since I was sexually dominant, and I embraced this moment. Lynette was panting and moaning as I fucked her with my pent up force, youthful energy and skill. I was all sweaty from this lengthy event. “OH YES!” she sobbed. I had achieved one of my goals, that I could still made a hot girl cum with my dick. With a few more pumps of my slicked up cock, I let out a series of grunts as I exploded in her. My other goal of making a baby was reached.

“You were awesome!” Nick said to me later when were in bed. “Like riding a bicycle” I laughed. “Considering it was your first time with a woman, you were pretty good yourself!” I said. “Aww, I thought of you…” In the morning I sucked him off before he left for work.

“That way the baby will really be both of ours” explained Nick to me when he told me his plan weeks ago.

The next night, I fucked Lynette first and then Nick took his turn. That pattern of us alternating went on, until a few weeks later, when Lynette became pregnant. The day we got the good news, Nick and I celebrated by going back to our sex routine of him fucking me. Our mutual passion and my craving for having his cock in me excited Lynette, who watched us. 

“I have no interest in taking care of a kid. I did my best, but I once had to have an abortion. Now, it’ll be nice to know I have one around. You two will make great parents. You can send me pictures. The fee will put my retirement account over the top” said Lynette when Nick brought her home to meet me months earlier.

Lynette was from Wisconsin, her real name was Estelle. “Lynette is my stage name.” She came to Manhattan when she was 18 to be actress. She took classes and worked as a waitress. “I was in a Chekov play Off-Off-Broadway for no money and even with great tips had not much left over after paying rent. After a year of not getting anywhere, I started going on ‘dates.’ I knew someone who knew someone, and I was being setup to go out with guys. One got me a nice apartment and paid the rent and gave me an allowance. I was still meeting up with other guys. Hotel rooms mostly. Nothing sleazy. I had something to sell that men wanted. That’s how it goes. You know all about that..”

Nick’s partner Stan had a thing with Lynette. Though Nick wasn’t into it, he met Lynette and got to know her. “I’m done. Guys want young. After 25, certainly by 30, it’s time to pack up your douchebag. I’ve saved enough to  quit, move to Miami and start over. No more of these winters.”

“That’s a lot of money!” I said to Nick when he told me the offer he made to Lynette for her to have our baby. $100,000 plus all related expenses and taking care of her with until the birth. “I not going into detail, but being on the job, I can handle it.” He said.

For nine months the three of us lived together in harmony. Lynette gave birth and two weeks later left. Nick insisted that I be on the birth certificate as the father. He legally adopted Leo and so we all have the same last name. I’m going to college part-time now so I can share taking care of Leo with Nick. Ilona is a very pretty and expert 24-year-old doula who is helping us with Leo. Life is really special now.