Convincing

Jonathan awoke in a manner that was not particularly pleasant or unpleasant. His eyes fluttered open, quickly adjusting to the light in the space to reveal his own room as usual. However, Jonathan soon had a start, as he realized the position he was in: he was tied to the posts of his bed frame with rope, while his head was tilted up a bit using a pillow.

“What the-!?” He exclaimed as he bucked against his restraints. His efforts were to no avail; the ropes were quite firmly secured. With no other option, he decided to yell “Help!”

Jonathan heard a stirring outside of his door, and swore he heard a somewhat familiar voice say “He’s awake.”

The knob of his door slowly turned and in walked two figures that Jonathan certainly recognized. It was his roommate Derrick and Derrick’s boyfriend Arron. The two had always seemed like an oddly matched couple. On one side, there was Derrick, a very tall and very muscular man, who displayed a confidant, at times even flirtatious attitude. Then there was Aaron, almost the exact opposite. He was short, thin, and didn’t speak much at all. Jonathan could have sworn that he’d barely heard the guy talk in the months that he’d known him. Their only sort of similarity was their dark hair, but even there they differed, as Derrick’s hair was closer to blonde, while Aaron’s was clearly more brown.

“Guys, what’s going on!?“

As usual, Derrick did the talking for the couple. “Isn’t it obvious? We tied you up.” he said playfully, clearly knowing that what he’d said wasn’t a real answer.

“Okay, but why would you do this? Let me go!” Jonathan pulled against the ropes once again.

Derrick chuckled at his efforts “No use doing that Jonny. Remember, I was in the scouts. Sure as I got that merit badge, those knots are tight.” He flicked one of the ropes.

Jonathan grimaced at being called Jonny, but chose not to acknowledge it, as he couldn’t exactly fight back given his position. “What’s going on?” he demanded.

Derrick sighed “I’m afraid to tell you that you put yourself here Jonny.”

“What!?”

“Metaphorically.” put in Aaron, giving Jonathan a slight shock upon hearing his voice.

“Yeah, metaphorically. You trapped yourself by not being true to you.” Jonathan’s baffled look only intensified, so Derrick continued “Still not getting what I mean? Alright, let me lay it out for you: you’re gay Jonny.”

Jonathan’s eyes widened “What!? No, I’m not gay!”

“See, that right there is your problem. Being gay isn’t a big deal Jonny. You just need to be true to yourself.”

“Look, I’m fine with gay people, but I’m telling you, I’m not gay!”

“Really? Well, then I guess you won’t mind looking at a little video we have for you.”

At Derrick’s words, Aaron turned on the TV that was in Jonathan’s room. A video was already pulled up on the screen and Derrick quickly grabbed the remote and pressed play. At first there was only a shot of a seemingly empty locker room, but soon a twinkish man walked onto the scene.

“I think he looks like your type Jonny.” Derrick said as he snickered. Jonathan ignored him.

The man on screen saw an open locker. He went to close it but, just as he did, seemed to notice something in the locker. He pulled it out, revealing it to be a jockstrap. The man put the garment up to his nose and sniffed it, clearly pleased with what he smelled. He quickly sat down on a bench, smelling it again and beginning to touch himself. Jonathan gasped subtlety and looked away from the screen

It apparently wasn’t subtle enough to escape Derrick’s notice, though “What’s the matter Jonny? You’re not gay, right? Then you should have no problem watching this and not getting hard.“

Jonathan looked back to the television. The twink moved his body sensually as he continued to smell the dirty underwear and his length grew.

“Look at that.” Aaron said with a sexual undertone in his voice.

“I know. He looks like he’s got a big one. What do you think Jonny?”

Jonathan didn’t answer, both because he didn’t want to give Derrick the satisfaction of doing so, and because he had to focus on avoiding becoming hard himself.

The man now had his cock out and was slowly jacking himself off. A second, much larger man now appeared, coming quietly from behind the first man. For the moment he didn’t intervene, instead opting to watch the smaller man from a small distance while palming at his own bulge. Soon enough, though, he approached and tapped the smaller one on the shoulder. He began to speak, but the large man simply shushed him and dropped his gym shorts to reveal a semi-erect length.

“Damn…” Aaron said lustfully.

“And that’s only a semi.” Derrick replied, continuing his boyfriend’s thought.

The small man looked the other in the eyes as if he was innocently questioning if he could really do what he wanted to do. The tall man simply nodded down at his length with a confidant smirk that said “Get on that dick.” The twink didn’t hesitate after that as he almost immediately began sucking. As he did, his ass stuck out, showing that it was quite large for his size.

“Now Jonny,” Derrick started without looking away from the screen “make sure to not imagine yourself as that guy. Don’t imagine your dick getting sucked by that hot piece of ass.” By now the twink was already taking all of the buff man’s sizable rod in his mouth “I mean…you’re not gay, right? You don’t need to think about him sucking you off, even if he looks like he’s damn good at it.”

Jonathan shuddered silently at Derrick’s words. He knew quite well what he was doing, but that didn’t stop it from working. Despite Jonathan’s best efforts, his cock began to grow. He couldn’t look away and couldn’t figure out why. Perhaps it was because he thought Derrick would catch him again, or perhaps part of him didn’t want to. Either way, he knew he was in trouble, especially as the small man began moaning due both to the buff man fucking his mouth and to the twink jacking himself off.

Jonathan made some sort of involuntary noise as his growing dick was pushed down by his tight pants. Derrick immediately picked up on it “Hmm? What’s wrong there Jonny? Does the totally-not-gay boy have a little hard-on? Now why could that be? Certainly not because of the video. After all…you don’t like boys like that, right?”

“Th-this isn’t fair! You put all those thoughts of getting my cock sucked in my mind.”

“I don’t put anything in your mind. You’re the one that thought about.” When Jonathan’s only response was to look away, Derrick continued “Aaron, turn that off and then…do your thing.”

Aaron seemed to take pleasure in that, his eyes lighting up as he quickly moved to stop the video. Jonathan, on the other hand, gulped “His…thing?”

“You’ll see.” He lowered his voice to a whisper “I swear if you hurt him I’ll knock your lights out.” Jonathan thought he should definitely take the threat seriously.

Aaron finished tinkering with the TV, then turned to Jonathan. He climbed onto his bed and got between Jonathan’s legs.

Jonathan’s eyes widened “Did you just realize?” Derrick laughed.

Aaron scrunched down so that his head was aligned with Jonathan’s private area. He ran his hand across Jonathan’s thigh while he unbuttoned the captive man’s pants. As Jonathan’s breath hitched, Aaron pulled his pants down as much as he could. He then shot Jonathan a devious smile before lowering his head. Aaron moved so that his nose was in the space Jonathan’s balls and his thighs, then inhaled deeply.

Aaron clearly liked what he smelled, as he let out a pleasure filled “Mmm” which almost seemed involuntary.

“Yeah, he likes his guys sweaty. Guess it gets him off. Works good for me, since I don’t have to shower before we have sex. You should see how he jumps on me after I come home from the gym.”

As if it was a reward, the smallest man in the room began squeezing and rubbing Jonathan’s package while he smelled again.

“Ah!” Jonathan exclaimed at the sudden contact.

“He likes your dick Jonny. Lucky you.” Aaron moved his head to the same position on the other side, changing the hand he used to grope Jonathan as he did “Look at him, horny for you just from your smell…just like that twink in the video. He wants to serve you…and all you have to do is let him.”

As of to illustrate Derrick’s point, Aaron moved his hand away from the clothed cock and replaced it with his mouth, running his tongue slowly up and down the length of it. Jonathan felt as if he would make another noise, but was able to control himself.

Soon enough, as Aaron made his way up Jonathan’s length once more, he went past the covered head and hooked his mouth onto the band of the captive man’s underwear. He looked to Jonathan, eyes filled with utter lust, then slowly peeled the garment down. Jonathan’s dick finally popped out, hitting Aaron in the face, though he didn’t seem to mind at all.

Derrick piped up again “You’re pretty big Jonny. Course…I’m bigger, but I’m sure a lot of guys…oh no, wait, ‘girls’…would prefer to take what you’ve got. Not everyone can handle a monster like mine.” Jonathan shuddered at the thought “Oh my god…did you just fucking think about it!?” Derrick laughed rather hard at the notion, which further caused Jonathan to blush “How the hell do you think you’re straight?”

“I-I could…be bi.” Jonathan said weakly.

“Sure. Sounds totally believable when you’ve got a rock hard cock, my boyfriend is about to blow you, and you just thought about me pounding you.”

“You guys forced this on me!”

Derrick sighed “Babe, keep going. He’s almost there.”

Aaron immediately followed his boyfriend’s commands. He at first only brushed his hand over Jonathan’s upper thigh, which then translated to him lightly rubbing around his balls and up his cock. Jonathan started to breathe harder.

“Just a little touch feels so good, right Jonny?” Jonathan didn’t respond. He couldn’t. He was incredibly turned on and couldn’t explain why. “More Aaron.”

Aaron put his mouth just above Jonathan’s rod. However, instead of lowering himself down, he let out some saliva, letting it fall onto the cock. He took his hand and spread it across the entire length. He let his spit fall once again, and used his thumb to run it over the head. With his other hand he fondled Jonathan’s balls.

Jonathan shuddered and gasped at the feeling. “Funny that you haven’t told Aaron to stop yet.” said Derrick with confidence in his voice. Aaron spit on the rod once more and jerked it more quickly; additionally, he put his nose under Jonathan’s balls and sniffed there. “You could have been screaming no this whole time, but you haven’t said that once. Why’s that Jonny?”

Jonathan closed his eyes: he thought Derrick was right. He was really enjoying this. Derrick and Aaron were turning him out and he was enjoying it. More than enjoying it, he was actually getting off on it. He felt half helpless…and half helplessly lustful.

Aaron moved his mouth up, putting one of Jonathan’s balls in without ceasing to jerk his dick. He massaged it, roiling it skillfully in his mouth before moving to the other and doing the same motion.

“Ah-haa! Aaahhh!” Jonathan shouted, almost in ecstasy.

“Okay, stop Aaron.”

At his boyfriend’s words, Aaron did as he was told. He sat up and cracked his neck.

Jonathan opened his eyes again and looked to Derrick “H-huh…?”

Derrick tilted his head to the side and looked up “Well, since you’re not gay, there’s no reason for little Aaron to give you a proper blowjob, is there? That’s a shame. His mouth is amazing.“ He then looked back to the tied up man “Unless…do you have something to tell me?”

“U-Umm…”

“‘I’m gay Derrick.’ That’s all it takes Jonny. Just say you’re gay like we know you are…like you know you are.”

“I-I…uhh…”

“Don’t you want even more Jonny? Just think about how that guy in the video felt when he got to fuck that twink’s mouth. Think how good it’ll feels to get your dick sucked…and how good it’ll feel when you get to cum in his mouth. He’ll swallow every bit of course.”

“P-please…please.”

“That’s not enough Jonny. I want to hear you say it. ‘I’m gay Derrick.’ Fucking say it.”

Jonathan’s desire was starting to overwhelm everything else. Why was he denying himself a release? Everything he’d felt up until now told him that Derrick was right. Was admitting how he was feeling really going to cost him anything?

As Jonathan was thinking, Derrick spoke “Well, I guess you’ve made your choice. C’mon babe, let’s go.”

Before Aaron could move at all, Jonathan shouted “No!”

“Hmm? What is it Jonny? If you’ve got something important to say, you’d better spit it out, or we’re leaving.”

“I…I’m gay…” Jonathan sat said sheepishly.

“What was that?”

“I’m gay Derrick! I don’t know how you knew more than I did, or how on earth it’s true, but you were right! I’m gay. Please…please suck me off. Let me cum, please!”

Derrick smiled and patted Jonathan’s shoulder “There you go Jonny! That wasn’t so hard, was it? Now, time to give you what you really need. Ready to get your mind and your cock blown?” Jonathan only nodded as a response “Aaron, suck the man till he’s happy.”

Aaron smiled “With pleasure.”

This time, Aaron didn’t tease at all. He lowered himself once again and put his mouth straight onto Jonathan’s throbbing erection. Right off the bat, Jonathan started to moan as Aaron took the head of his dick, swirled his wicked tongue around it, then licked the underside.

“Ah, that’s his signature right there! Feels damn good, huh?”

“Y-yeah…wow!” Jonathan gasped out.

Aaron started going down on Jonathan, bobbing his head and taking more each time. This was all accompanied by the small man fondling his balls.

“Isn’t it good to be gay?”

“If this is what it’s like…”

While Jonathan’s pleasure from before had somewhat subsided, he knew he still wouldn’t last long in the care of someone like Aaron. He must have been more than just a little experienced.

“Here Jonny, lemme give you another little treat.” Derrick walked behind Aaron and put his hand on his boyfriend’s waistband. “It’s a nice view for ya.” Aaron lifted his bottom half up a bit so that Derrick could pull his shorts down, all while continuing to blow Jonathan as if it was a job he was getting paid millions of dollars to do.

When Derrick got his lover’s shorts and underwear off, it revealed his large ass. Just like the small man in the video, it was disproportionately large for his size.

“Look at that!” said Derrick, leaving a slight pause between each word. He grabbed Aaron’s butt cheeks and squeezed them “Look at this fucking cake! Doesn’t he have a nice ass Jonny?”

Aaron now took his mouth off of Jonathan and began paying attention to his shaft, licking it dutifully.

Meanwhile, Jonathan was thinking about Derrick’s question. “Umm…”

“What, do you think that you can’t tell him that because he’s taken? Don’t worry about it. You’re gay, right? Pay a compliment to another gay man. Let him know what you like. Plus…giving him a compliment on his butt will make him suck you even better. Tell the man he’s got a nice ass.”

Jonathan doubted that was possible for Aaron to suck him better, but was willing to take the opportunity “A-Aaron you…you’ve got a n-nice ass…” said Jonathan, stuttering both because it was awkward and because of the pleasure he was feeling.

“Damn right he does!” Derrick slapped his boyfriend hard on his right ass cheek, which Aaron seemed to enjoy immensely, growling as it happened.

As thanks for the compliment, Aaron performed his signature move on Jonathan once again. Jonathan screeched in pleasure as he released precum. Aaron, of course, took it all in stride.

“Heh, you’re close huh?” Jonathan nodded “I can tell. He’s a good little cocksucker, isn’t he?” Jonathan shot a questioning look at Derrick “What? He loves when I call him that while he’s horny…especially when he’s down on someone.” When Jonathan’s confusion didn’t subside, Derrick explainer further “He’s into it cause…well, that’s exactly what he is. He’s my little cock sucking bitch boy. Isn’t that right babe?”

“Mmm.” Aaron moaned out without lifting his head.

“That means yes. Heh, you didn’t take your mouth off if it for even one second. You really are a cock loving bitch.” Derrick laughed and slapped Aaron’s other cheek “I couldn’t believe how lucky I was to find a cock sucker like him. He can deepthroat my dick and he does a fucking amazing job with it. And lemme remind you, I am damn big. Most guys just can’t handle it. I like to joke that he doesn’t talk a lot because he’s better at this…but it might not be a joke. You might not expect it, but he’s horny as all hell too; he’s down to suck me off pretty much whenever…and, heh, wherever too. Oh and…” Derrick slapped both sides of Aaron’s ass simultaneously “…can’t forget this. Yep, he’s pretty much the perfect little bitch.” Derrick shot a look at Jonathan “And I’m letting you use him. Be thankful.”

Jonathan only caught parts of what Derrick said to him. He was busy having his cock worshiped, clearly lost in pleasure.

“Give him just a little more. Thrust up and fuck his mouth. He can take it. After all…he loves dick however he can get it.”

That Jonathan certainly did hear. He quickly began pushing his hips up, driving his rod into Aaron’s mouth. He swallowed it all. It was now Aaron’s turn to shoot a look to Jonathan. It was one that told him that he was ready for his cum.

At almost the exact same time, Derrick said “It’s time Jonny. Give him your cum.”

Jonathan closed his eyes and started involuntarily pushing himself up as he squirted cum into Aaron’s mouth. The small man didn’t stop sucking as the captive shot load after load into him. Finally, Jonathan was able to settle. He wasn’t used to cumming so much or blowjobs in general, so he laid on the bed having to catch his breath.

Aaron finally took his mouth off of Jonathan and went to stand by Derrick. “Did you like that dick you little bitch?” he said.

“Yes sir.” Aaron responded “He has a real nice one.”

“Better than mine?”

“No one’s dick is better than yours sir.”

“Damn straight…well…no, no one here is that.” He laughed “Tell me again, what’s your place in the bedroom?

“My place is…on my knees, sir…worshiping you as your cock sucking bitch.”

“For how long?”

“For as long as we’re together, so…hopefully forever sir.”

Derrick smiled at his boyfriend’s statement, bent down, and the two shared kissed.

Aaron then reached down and groped Derrick’s cock through his pants “You’re still fully hard. Would you like me to suck you off next sir?”

“No…I’ve got a plan.” Derrick looked back to Jonathan as he loosened his belt “I think it’s time to break in my new bitch.”