• Mormon Boyz
    • 67 score
    • 25 May 2014

    Mormon Boyz

    We don't often see truly unique themes, but Mormon Boyz definitely has one. Amateur Mormon guys strip out of their suits, take off their conservative underwear, and jerk off or suck and fuck on camera. There are 108 downloadable videos, the site says it updates weekly, and there's something kinky about the religious aspect of this site.

    http://www.mormonboyz.com

  • Club Amateur USA
    • 78 score
    • 19 May 2014

    Club Amateur USA

    Club Amateur USA features real amateur straight guys exploring their sexuality by getting massaged, jerked off and sometimes sucked by a guy - some dildo play, and lots of solo jerk-off sessions, too. Offering 464 downloadable videos and 2 weekly updates, this site delivers plenty of extras and lots of straight and bi-curious cock.

    http://www.clubamateurusa.com

  • Only Real Guys
    • 59 score
    • 10 May 2014

    Only Real Guys

    Only Real Guys is a true amateur site that offers a good sized collection of pics and videos of straight amateurs showing their cocks, asses, naked bodies or bulges. You'll find lots of different guys in various categories. If you're into real amateurs getting wild or drunk on film, this site will keep you busy.

    http://www.onlyrealguys.com

  • Lads Next Door Editor Pick
    • 75 score
    • 1 May 2014

    Lads Next Door

    Lads Next Door offers hot English amateurs - average guys, twinks and hunks - with juicy uncut cocks. There are 117 exclusive downloadable videos and an update every week (sometimes more than one). The site is well done and the guys are REAL hot and horny amateurs.

    http://www.ladsnextdoor.com

  • Ex Gay BFs Trial $1.00
    • 42 score
    • 23 Apr 2014

    Ex Gay BFs

    Ex Gay BFs offers horny amateur guys from twinks to daddies sucking and fucking or jacking off. The site is no longer updating, but you do get access to a lot of free bonus content. 106 downloadable videos, but the content doesn't match what is being advertised on the tour.

    http://www.exgaybfs.com

  • KB Castings Trial $6.95
    • 76 score
    • 19 Apr 2014

    KB Castings

    KB Castings offers gay porn hopefuls in their audition videos for Kristen Bjorn. Mostly European hunks (plus a few South Americans) with uncut cocks in hardcore action; experienced performers are usually paired with newcomers. 346 streaming videos, and a new one is added weekly.

    http://www.kbcastings.com

  • Saggers Gone Wild
    • 54 score
    • 15 Apr 2014

    Saggers Gone Wild

    Saggers Gone Wild features real amateur street thugs in low-hanging and saggy pants. The site has some issues and doesn't seem to update (or if so, not often), but the content is unique and entertaining if you are into saggers, who show off their boxers and bodies.

    http://www.saggersgonewild.com

  • Gemini Men Editor Pick
    • 83 score
    • 17 Mar 2014

    Gemini Men

    100% exclusive and very anally-oriented homemade videos with straight guys jacking off and exploring their butts with fingers, dildos and sometimes a cock. Over 550 downloadable videos, 2 to 3 videos added every week. Real amateurs, lots of ass play.

    http://www.geminimen.com

  • Straight boys jerk off Trial $1.00
    • 59 score
    • 4 Mar 2014

    Straight boys jerk off

    Straight Boys Jerk Off features horny 18 to 25 year old guys jacking off or sucking and fucking a buddy on camera. The 260 videos are good amateur quality, but sizes could be bigger and the site no longer updates. Two exclusive bonus sites help take up the slack.

    http://www.straightboysjerkoff.com

  • Straight Bro
    • 58 score
    • 27 Feb 2014

    Straight Bro

    Straight Bro is a new site offering horny amateur straight guys being pushed passed their sexual limits. The site offers 18 streaming videos and has added 4 vids in 7 weeks. Some very hot action.

    http://www.straightbro.com

  • Rate These Guys
    • 73 score
    • 21 Feb 2014

    Rate These Guys

    Rate These Guys features straight amateurs who will do almost anything to get members to vote for them so they can win cash prizes. Offering 430 homemade video clips, a fun theme and updates every 2 to 3 days, this is a unique, interesting site.

    http://www.ratetheseguys.com

  • Dick Show
    • 56 score
    • 11 Feb 2014

    Dick Show

    Dick Show offers an exclusive collection of horny amateur guys stroking their cocks and getting off. Over 300 videos, newer vids are streaming only, older vids are on the small side but some are downloadable. The site is good sized with updates dated weekly.

    http://www.dickshow.com

  • Joe Schmoe Videos Trial $1.95
    • 73 score
    • 5 Feb 2014

    Joe Schmoe Videos

    Joe Schmoe Videos delivers straight trailer trash bad boys, covered in tattoos and horny as hell. There is a good mix of solo and hardcore action in the 208 videos, and the site adds 3 updates every week. A great site if you're looking for real amateur rednecks.

    http://www.joeschmoevideos.com

  • Downlo Boys
    • 58 score
    • 2 Feb 2014

    Downlo Boys

    Downlo Boys offers horny amateur straight boys caught on video in their first jackoff shoots or experimenting with other guys. The site offers 32 exclusive, downloadable videos and regular weekly updates. Video quality could be better, but the men themselves are hot regular guys.

    http://www.downloboys.com

  • Spunk Worthy Editor Pick
    • 80 score
    • 20 Jan 2014

    Spunk Worthy

    Straight guys, surfers, military guys, frat boys, and amateurs from Southern California in their first jack off, handjobs, and oral servicing on camera. Hairy and smooth, lots of inked guys. 284 exclusive episodes, new video added every week plus 78 exclusive behind the scenes vids.

    http://www.spunkworthy.com

  • Gay Snare
    • 55 score
    • 12 Jan 2014

    Gay Snare

    Gay Snare sends women out to find guys to suck and get fucked by their boyfriends or buddies. A mix of tricked straight guys and gay matchmaking. Nine DRM-free videos, 3 updates scheduled next month. Full members get 2 bonus sites. Horny Euro guys with uncut cocks.

    http://www.gaysnare.com

  • Privoy
    • 63 score
    • 25 Dec 2013

    Privoy

    Privoy offers exclusive videos of real amateurs from 18 to 21 in mostly solo masturbation action. The 84 videos seem to be homemade and they're available to stream. The site has added 4 videos in the last month, and I must say that some of the guys here are hot!

    http://www.privoy.com

  • Buzz West
    • 61 score
    • 20 Dec 2013

    Buzz West

    When it comes to all-American amateurs and regular guys, Buzz West is a good place to see 'em in action. I like their 319 videos but wasn't so thrilled that they only allow 1 download at a time, and was disappointed that the site stopped updating. Still, hot guys, some ex-military.

    http://www.buzzwest.com

  • Gay Hot
    • 56 score
    • 8 Nov 2013

    Gay Hot

    Gay Hot features real amateur home videos, not fakes. These are real guys jacking their dicks, playing with dildos, and some film their private sex sessions. Downloadable videos with no DRM.

    http://www.gayhot.com

  • Hard BFs
    • 49 score
    • 9 Oct 2013

    Hard BFs

    Hard BFs delivers amateurs - regular guys, mature men and hairy first-timers - as they strip, stroke and shoot their loads on camera. The 54 videos are fairly good quality, but the downloadable versions are small. Updates are iffy, but members get 2 gay bonus sites.

    http://www.hardbfs.com