New York Straight Men

17 Jun 2023 Score 70 / 100 newyorkstraightmen.com Not Mobile friendly


  • Videos 4 stars
  • Pictures 4 stars
  • Unique 5 stars
  • Size 4 stars
Review score 70
  • 4 stars Cost
  • 0 stars Updates
  • 3 stars Usability
  • 3 stars Claims
NYSM tour page Click here to visit New York Straight Men

Introduction to newyorkstraightmen.com

New York Straight Men invites real straight amateur guys to their apartment with promises of great blowjobs - the kind they don't get at home. Lots of hairy and masculine men who get their dicks sucked by other dudes, often for the first time. The site offers 649 exclusive downloadable videos.

Skip to full review

Since Last Review

  • Site has stopped adding new content

NYSM Topics

Video info

Videos are downloadable

649 exclusive videos. Newer downloads are good amateur quality in MP4 format at 1280x720 and WMV sized at 960x540 and a QuickTime. Oldest vids in WMV format at 640x480 at decent amateur quality. Other sizes available. Only MP4's are mobile compatible, others must be downloaded before playing.

Picture info

Most episodes have corresponding picture sets. Pics are digital stills; newer from 1920x1080 to 1200x900 at good amateur quality, older at 675x900 at fairly good amateur quality. No slideshows or zip files, pics can be individually downloaded. 30 to 50 photos per set.

Site issues

This site no longer updates!

Site is recycling updates instead of adding new content.

Membership cost of New York Straight Men

  • Monthly: $25.95 (recurring every 30 days)
  • Monthly: $34.95 (30 days, non-recurring)
  • Quarterly: $69.95 (90 days, non recurring)

New York Straight Men Review

New York Straight Men offers exactly what you'd expect - horny straight men from New York – and if you like watching a man sitting back while a cocksucker goes to work on his meat, this site is for you. The men getting blown are almost all amateurs first-timers, although many do return for repeats. It's been quite a while since we last visited the site, so join me while I head back and see what's been happening.

The guys here are all amateurs, and I believe that the majority really are straight, and most of them are in their twenties, thirties, and forties. There's some diversity when it comes to the men; while most are White, you will also find some Black men, Latinos and men with Italian or other European roots. Some are muscular, others have average physiques or a few extra pounds on them, and they often have natural body hair. You might wonder why those straight macho guys choose to appear on a gay site. Often they're just horny and looking for a quick blowjob or an ass to fuck - a mouth is a mouth and an ass is an ass, right? Some of them are truly curious about sex with another guy, and sometimes they're looking for the kind of sex they don't get at home - a sloppy blowjob, sometimes a rim job, or an anal fuck.

The videos at New York Straight Men are mostly duos. In them, the straight guys get serviced by the house cocksuckers, who are gay guys, and sometimes they might even get serviced by other straight guys. Most of the men get their cocks sucked and their asses eaten before they blow their loads with cum often landing on the cocksucker's face. There are some solo jack-off videos and hardcore videos featuring anal fucking, too. Also worth noting is that the site has tended to use each cocksucker multiple times before swapping him out, and why not? These blow boys know how to make a man cum.

There are 649 exclusive videos in the members area. The newer productions are available in MP4 format at 1280x720 at good amateur quality, QuickTime format at 854x480, and WMV format at 960x540, while very oldest videos are in WMV format only and display at 640x480. In between, you'll find a variety of other sizes. Some videos can be clicked and saved, others require you to right-click and save them, and many require a few extra clicks as Chrome thinks these files are not safe, but they are. The MP4 videos can be streamed in your browser, but the rest of the formats need to be downloaded to play, which means they can't be streamed at all and you must download them to play them on mobiles; the oldest vids, available only in WMV format, won't play on most phones.

Most of the videos come with matching picture sets. The pics are digital stills sized between 675x900 and 1200x900, depending on the age of the episode, and the very newest come in at 1920x1080. The images are good amateur quality, and the action is captured extremely well. There are some great close-ups, too. There are 30 to 50 photos per gallery. While you can save individual images, there are no zip files to download full sets at once. The picture viewer does not have a slideshow feature but there are "next" and "previous" navigation buttons.

Now let's talk about issues. We reviewed NewYorkStraightMen in March of 2015 and found 612 videos, then in 2018 there were 649 videos, and now in 2023, the site hasn't grown at all. That means that it has stopped filming new scenes around 2017. They seem to be recycling the videos to keep the front page looking fresh, so the videos are out of production order, so you'll find newer ones alongside older ones, and this means a variety of formats and sizes. The oldest NewYorkStraightMen videos, as mentioned, don't have mobile compatible versions and many of the videos need to be downloaded before they can be watched. The tour says they add a new scene every five days, but we've already established that this is no longer the case. Still, there are a lot of videos to keep you going for a good long while, and I loved watching many of my favorites again.

New York Straight Men has been delivering straight amateur guys from New York since 2005, and they have built up a good sized collection over the years. There are 649 exclusive, downloadable videos, most with matching photo sets of straight guys getting their cocks sucked till they cum. There are some solo videos and hardcore videos containing penetration, too, and you can expect plenty of juicy closeups in all the videos. If you decide to join via the monthly membership and stay a while, there is a loyalty discount after 90 days. The older videos aren't mobile compatible, and I'm sorry NYSM stopped filming new scenes, as I always enjoyed their sessions. If you've never been a member, you'll love watching these real straight men getting their dicks sucked. 

Things we disliked

  • Site is recycling updates
  • Oldest vids not available for mobiles
  • Most videos can't be streamed
  • Older vids not as sharp as newer ones
  • Inconsistent video sizes and formats

Click here to visit New York Straight Men

NYSM Screenshots

About Reviews

Online since 1999, GayDemon is a trusted guide to gay porn sites. On this page you can find a in-depth, detailed review of New York Straight Men with our honest opinion about this site. The review outline what you can expect to find as a member if you subscribe to New York Straight Men. The review was as accurate as possible when it was written on the 17 Jun 2023, but sites constantly change. GayDemon cannot guarantee that you will find the exact same content or features when you visit. Please contact me or leave a comment if you have any questions.

Legal stuff

GayDemon only write reviews of gay porn sites that are legal and safe to visit. This review contain our honest options, however GayDemon receive commission from a membership sale if you decide to join this site. We can only continue to write reviews with your support through your purchases. (38780)