I'm Your Boy Toy focuses on horny twinks from 18 to around 25 getting nailed by men in their thirties and daddies aged forty or a little older. The twinks are mostly smooth, slender, and many are boyish and cute with hard dicks. They're partnered with men in their prime, many of whom are sexy, bearded hunks with great bodies including some with hairy chests and asses. Daddies include very sexy porn star Marcus Ruhl, salt and pepper bearded daddy Mike Manchester, bald and hairy Adam Russo, and masculine star Dominic Pacifico, while some of the twinks are also well-known performers like sexy Brit Skylar Blu, super cute Kyler Moss, and brunette Texan Andy Taylor. There are also lesser-known faces like boyish Ian Levine and silver-haired Dave Powers.
The set-ups here are fairly minimal and get us right into the action. A bearded teacher comes by to hook up with the college student he used to fuck, and as soon as we establish that mom is out, the kissing begins. A married man sneaks around with a horny twink for some fun on the side with no build-up at all, which was fine by me - they get right to the dick sucking. Or in a bit of a role reversal, a cocky twink goes out to catch some rays by his family's pool, and the muscular man cleaning the pool (Marcus Ruhl) asks him if he wants to fuck - soon the guys are trading blowjobs, then Marcus gets his ass eaten and then takes that twink cock up his ass.
I'm Your Boy Toy offers 42 DRM-free videos, and the site currently adds a new episode with video and photos once a month. The vids are offered in DRM-free MP4 format, the largest sized at 1920x1080 at good amateur quality or better plus three smaller sizes including a smaller HD version at 1280x720 and two standard sizes that should work for most mobiles. The videos can also be streamed in the same resolutions, and the larger sizes look good at full screen. The videos play smoothly, and sound is good on most of them, although I did watch one that was a bit tinny.
Now let's talk about pics. Each episode comes with a set of pictures. These are good amateur quality digital stills that are sharp and clear, sized at around 667x1000, although they could have been a little better lit. A few of the photo sets contain images that may be screencaps rather than digital stills, and these are shown at 1000x667. While just a little over-sharpened, these are good enough to pass for digital stills. Each set can be downloaded in a zip file or you can save the images you like individually. There are no slideshows, but you can navigate from pic to pic easily.
I'm Your Boy Toy members get access to four or five bonus sites, depending on how you look at it, plus there's more extras. One of the sites, Bang Me Sugar Daddy, also features twinks with guys in their thirties and forties, and while this site no longer updates, there are 52 videos. There's also My Gay Boss (58 scenes but no updates), My Husband is Gay (56 scenes, also no updates), and Phoenixxx (133 videos but no recent updates) plus Phoenixxx Twinks (only 14 scenes but this site seems to be updating), 16 Phoenixxx bonus videos, a collection of interviews with the Phoenixxx network models including some of the guys from I'm Your Boy Toy. Last is a collection of 316 bonus vids.
The site does have some downsides. First is the pre-checked offer on the billing page that, if left checked, will sign you up for a second recurring site membership when you join I'm Your Boy Toy. Next are the ads. There's a trailer at the top of every page that is actually an ad for another site; there's also eight animated thumbs at the bottom of every page that lead to a third-party cam site. And in the middle of every episode page is banner spot that breaks up the episode's stuff and some of the banners can be mistaken for content. The site only adds a new video once a month, and most of the bonus sites don't update either. That means there's enough here to enjoy for a month or maybe two, but don't expect lots of new content to be added to the network.
I'm Your Boy Toy delivers on their site theme - every episode offers up a horny twink sucking and fucking (or getting fucked by) a man in his thirties or forties. The sex is hot as are the performers, many of whom are well-known porn stars, and the 42 videos are exclusive, look good, and can be downloaded, streamed, and watched on most mobile devices. The site updates once a month, and members get access to bonus sites from the same network plus performer interviews and more bonus videos. While I wish the site updated more often, overall I liked the content on offer at I'm Your Boy Toy, and it's always hot to watch twinks from 18 to around 25 with older men.