It took me awhile to figure out why I was so scared and cold...
I remembered a rough hand, a chloroform soaked rag, and nothing else.
Except that I wasn't with Jamie.
I awoke freezing cold and with a headache. There was ice on the walls and what looked like bags of meat in the corners. I was in a freezer.
I knew I had to get out soon, or else I'd freeze to death. I went to move toward the door, but I couldn't move. I looked down, and saw that my hands and feet were tied to a single chair in the middle of the freezer. I wondered why it was so cold, and then I realized I was naked from the waist down...
I was so scared I didn't know what to do. Where was I? Why would someone kidnap me? I hadn't done anything to anybody!
As if to answer my question, the door in front of me opened, and a burst of warmth flooded in. I reveled in it. Suddenly, a man entered, wearing jeans and a Pirates t-shirt. I recognized our high school mascot on the shirt, and thought it strange that I'd be kidnapped by someone I knew. Then I saw his face.
It was my football coach.
Coach Kiebach [Craig was his first name] was actually a pretty handsome man. He was about 6'5" tall, had a slight beer belly, and had the chiseled jaw line of a Hollywood actor. He had the tired look of a once hot and popular athlete in college who had stuck to coaching as a way to relive his glory days. He'd always seemed so nice, until the day he'd yelled at Jamie and made us run those laps. God, it felt like years ago. What was he up to?
'Yes, it's me,' he said, in a husky baritone. 'I bet you're confused as to your predicament.'
'You bet your ass I am. Why are you doing this to me?' I asked. I began to feel tears in my eyes, my confusion starting to spill over.
'You really don't know?' he asked. 'I thought you'd have figured it out by now. Didn't you feel may hand earlier?'
I had a thought, but surely I was wrong. Was Coach Kiebach in love with me?
'Yes,' he continued, as if he was reading my mind. 'I've been obsessed with you ever since you joined the team. That's why I never let you play in the games a lot! I wanted to keep you healthy and strong.'
'I wanted to keep you safe,' he snarled, circling my chair. I took a glance at his crotch out of habit and saw a bulge starting in his tight jeans.
'So, what, you're in love with me?' I asked, wanting to keep him talking. I was kind of afraid of what he might do...but also a little turned on. He looked like an older Jamie.
'I have been since I laid eyes on you. You're so fucking sexy, the way you wear your pants. They really accent your perfect ass, which I'm dying to taste,' he confessed. 'By the way, I was there and saw you suck Jamie off. I'll admit, I was jealous. But I beat my cock furiously thinking of you sucking him. I pictured it was me you were pleasing. My finger pushing in and out of your hot ass.'
He was right in front of me now, his hard cock testing the fabric of his jeans. My own prick started to get hard...
[what? He was a handsome guy!]
'I knew you'd never leave Jamie on your own, so I've decided to give you a little taste of a mature man. See what you're missing.'
With that, he unzipped his fly, unbuttoned his pants, and a 9 inch monster popped out of his jeans. I gasped.
'Jamie was my favorite at one time, but now you're the one I want. Your sexy mouth slobbering all over my dick. I bet you can take this cock well, can't you, boy?'
He took my open mouth as an invitation and shoved his cock right in. A moan escaped his lips, and he grabbed the back of my head, fucking my throat. He tasted wonderful, but I felt disgusting. I was cheating. My eyes began to water, but it was from shame.
Suddenly, Coach Kiebach became rigid, and I thought he was going to force me to eat his seed, but then I sensed someone else in the room. Coach keeled over, unconscious, and in his place stood the man of my dreams.
He began to cry.
'You're okay!' he sobbed.
'Okay? I just cheated on you! You must be furious with me!'
He just shushed me and then sat on my lap, kissing me with so much passion. Finally I felt alright.
'No babe,' he said. 'You didn't cheat. You had no choice! Don't worry, I'm not mad. I should have known he was going to try something when he messaged me today.'
Suddenly, everything clicked into place. The sudden closing of Facebook, his wanting to keep our relationship a secret, why Coach Kiebach was suddenly so angry with him all those months ago. I was in awe of Jamie. As it turns out, right before he'd first talked to me at practice, he'd just broken a fling off with Coach. That's why he'd been so angry with us that day.
'I'm sorry I've caused you so much trouble,' I said. 'I never meant to harm you or cause you such pain.'
'Stop,' he whispered, wiping my tears away. 'When I went looking for you, I found those movies scattered on the floor, I got scared and started searching. Then I found a rag by the door, and figured you might be back here. I had just come through the employee door when I heard a moan. Thank God I found you!'
My tears were flowing freely now. 'Jamie, I'm so sorry! I'm sorry I made you break it off with Coach.'
'Hey, hey,' he said in a soothing voice. 'I chose you. I'm yours, through the good an the bad. Craig is the bad guy here, not you. I love you, and I will never love anyone else.'
I kissed him. Our mouths didn't stop touching for at least 3 minutes.
I started shivering.
'You wanna get me out of here?' I asked him. 'My arms are starting to get numb.
He just stood up and looked at me in my predicament, and then his eyes fell upon my hard cock, and he gave me an impish grin.
'How about we make the best of this?' he asked, taking off his pants and underwear.
I could only nod. He walked over to me, his thick member swaying back and forth, and I took him in my mouth.
You'd think that with what had just happened I wouldn't want to do this again, but I trusted Jamie and loved him with every ounce of my being. Then, just as suddenly, he was moistening his fingers, and I knew what was coming.
He was going to fuck me.
But then he did something I didn't expect. He placed his long fingers behind his back and began playing with his own hole as I continued to suck him.
Then, he sat down on my cock.
'OH!' I screamed as pleasure I had never felt before escaped through every nerve ending in my body. We'd never tried him being the bottom before! His mouth found mine, stifling my moan with his tongue. He rocked up and down and kept going faster and faster. We kept it up for around ten minutes, and suddenly I felt his hole clench around my hard cock, and I couldn't stand it anymore! I released a good 15 spurts of cum into his tight ass. He cried out like he'd been shot, and I saw something white go whizzing past my head, then another hit me on the cheek. Jamie had ejaculated everywhere.
As we sat there, panting for a moment, he got up, and began to lick his own seed from where it had spilled on my body.
It was so erotic, watching this beauty of a man do things to me while I couldn't move.
After we'd exhausted ourselves twice more, he released me of my bonds and we got dressed, tying Coach Kiebach up where I had been. Jamie had knocked him out pretty well, but before leaving, Jamie punched him right in the eye. Normally, I would have seen this as overkill, but in the end, considering what he might have done to me, I thought it was justified.
We left him there.
We paid for our items, left the market, and drove home, spending four glorious nights together, snowed in from the outside world.
As for Coach Kiebach, we made an anonymous phone call, and it turns out that he was a wanted man for a lot of nasty things, including murder...so he went to jail.