Review recently updated on 2 May 2016
Boys First Time has been around since 2002, making it one of the longer-running gay sites around. The premise is that at least one of the guys in each scene is having his first gay sex experience. Many of the guys are between 18 and 24 years of age, but you will find a lot of models here who are a bit more mature, too well-built or little too hairy to be considered twinks or boys, as the site's title suggest. Still, the sex is pretty hot. It's been a couple of years since our last review and there have been some changes, so let's get inside.
There is quite a bit of variety when it comes to the guys, but most are college aged with slim or athletic bodies, and there are also some muscular jocks. The guys are mostly smooth, and the newer scenes feature some guys who are quite heavily inked. The majority of the performers are white, but there's a healthy offering of Latinos, a few black dudes and only a couple of Asian guys. The performers are mostly amateurs, but you will spot familiar faces like Johnny Rapid, Connor Maguire and others who were just getting started when their videos were filmed. The guys here are average to good looking, and they seem to be having fun. And of course there's a variety of cock sizes, both cut and uncut.
While some of the older scenes are jerk-off sessions, most of the videos are hardcore duos. The action at Boys First Time includes lots of kissing, cock sucking, ass fucking and guys blowing their loads; a few scenes also include sex toys play. The action is hot, and you can clearly tell these guys love to fuck. There are some steamy outdoor scenes, as well as guys getting off in bedrooms, living rooms, garages or basement man caves.
In "Mighty Penis", a couple of guys have to cut a game of Frisbee short due to rain. As they're pulling off their wet clothes in the laundry room, one guy grabs the others' bulge. "Whoa dude! That's gay" says the guy, but his stiffening cock says he's getting interested. After swapping blowjobs, the hesitant guy gets fucked on the floor. In a newer video called "Nice to Do You", Devon is a straight guy fresh out of jail and looking to make some money. After some introductory chit chat, the producer tells Brad to unzip Devon and suck his cock. By the end of the scene, Brad is getting boned doggy style, and loving it quite a lot for a straight guy.
Boys First Time has 581 videos in the member area in streaming MP4 format. The newest videos play at 958x538, the highest quality version looks good and there are three lower speeds, as well. The older videos are poor to average quality and play at 794x540, not a surprise since the older videos here were much smaller at their original size. And while the site offers full-screen mode, only the newer videos are worth watching this way. Gone are the WMVs the site used to offer, but I prefer the MP4s, however I was disappointed that the downloads are gone.
Each episode comes with a set of digital stills, although there might be some screencaps in the mix, as well. The photos are average to good amateur quality depending on the age of the pic set, and are sized at either 958x640 for landscape orientation but the portraits are only 428x640. On average there are between 150 to 200 pictures in a set, but I saw as many as 300. You can either browse the pictures in a hands-free slideshow, use forward and back controls or look through the thumbnails. You can no longer save images individually nor are there zip downloads.
Full members get access to four additional sites in the Reality Dudes hub - Dick Dorm features college-aged guy in horseplay and sex, Gay Revenge has jilted lovers fooling around on their cheating boyfriends, Papi offers Latinos in mostly interracial sex with white dudes, and Str8 Chaser is a new site where straight guys are offered lots of cash to have sex with the video producer. Altogether there are 184 bonus videos.
When we last reviewed the site in May 2014 there were 560 videos and now in April 2016 there are 581, but they haven't added a new scene in almost a year. And there are a few other issues. Trial memberships often offer limited access, but I couldn't find anything about that in the site's terms; still, don't be surprised if a trial doesn't give you full access. There's a pre-selected offer on the join page, but you can opt out of it in the dropdown menu, and joining the site automatically gives the site owner permission to send you commercial emails, but you should be able to opt out of these once the first one arrives. And as already mentioned, the older videos aren't very good quality.
Boys First Time is a good-sized site offering videos with matching picture sets of horny amateurs in hardcore suck and fuck action as well as some solo jerk-off sessions. The performers range from average guys-next-door to cute twinks and athletic jocks. There are currently 581 episodes, each with streaming videos, but the site no longer adds new content. Luckily full members get access to four bonus sites to help keep them busy. I liked watching all the amateur guys at Boys First Time including some a few who went on to do porn. The action is hot, and although some of the guys aren't that boyish, there's a nice variety of guys to keep members busy.