DJB | 19 Nov 2011 | My rating:

Be advised they falsely advertise the price and once you finally try to confirm it's a whopping $41.00. And, they have this big section highlighting second auditions for M/M play. There were only two scenes. I e-mailed my discontent with them. I would highly advise not joining! What a waste of money!!

grimm | 16 Jun 2011 | My rating:

i used to be a big fan of first auditions. the men seemed genuinely first time models, and they had an edge to them like the straight guys you see in the street. now the models seem to be getting progressively less hot and the site hardly ever updates. it says it updates but what it actually does is give you preview videos to their other sites. LAME. they need to get this site back to where it used to be, and stop charging above average for a site like this when all it does is show you clips from other sites they want you to join.

hhj | 12 May 2011 | My rating:

great content, great volume of content, scenes are a but short, and the newer scenes don't have good camera angles (seems to show a side angle).

james | 09 May 2011 | My rating:

this site has so much potential but honestly, right now at least, its not worth the money.
first off, there are only a couple hot guys, the rest of the guys are kind or boring. second, the videos are waaaayyyyyy short. i mean they're like five minutes.
idk, maybe its just me but i kind of feel ripped off by this site. i wish they would get other behind the scenes guys, the guy they have doing the measuring and stuff is kind of a douchebag and is boring to watch.

John J | 22 Dec 2010 | My rating:

First of all I was surprised when I got my receipt and the price had gone up $3 after signing up. I've tried to contact them - but haven't heard anything (surprise!).
"Funny" how many of the so called straight men turn up in a lot of the other gay videos (Groping hands etc) even though the people behind this claim that every ones sooo straight.

Sorry the site isn't convincing enough.

BUT a lot of the guys are really sexy and what better to look at when the shooting's on. And I don't mean the camera! (c:

Paul James | 03 Dec 2009 | My rating:

I love this site - I've been a member for just over a month & the lads change twice a week (so far)

As for them then appearing elsewhere on other sites... DUH! Clue is in the title!! Isnt this their FIRST audition to get more adult work?

M | 24 Nov 2009 | My rating:

I like this site a lot. It's different from most because it has a real feel about it. There are no scripts and genuine straight guys (some gay) get interviewed, have to undertake a physical naked and then wank and cum on camera.
The men on this site are normal and are from all over the world. It has a voyeuristic feel about it which is why I give it top marks! It is updated regularly and there is now a new, very exciting section called CMNM (Clothed Men, Nude Men)

Paul Smith | 09 Nov 2009 | My rating:

Used to love this site, but somehow the quality of the models became a little less convincing, especially when I'd see them turn up on the owner's other more fetish sites. The camera work and sound quality has sunk as well. Concept is excellent though (take note other producers).

C's | 07 Nov 2009 | My rating:

I was a member for a while and liked the vids, one thing that i didn't like was that updates took a long time, probably two guys per month or something like that, my credit card also got compromised and I knew it was on this site as I had never had that happen before until I joined. I like to rejoin but not willing to get my CC compromised again.

John | 01 Jul 2009 | My rating:

I was a member for awhile to this site and some of the stuff was very good. The best section is the Groping Hands section but unfortunately they put unrealistic costumes on the models that can really take away from the enjoyment of the action. It's a bit overpriced too. I'd give it a 5 but for the price and the costumes both of which would make me hesitate to rejoin it.

Roger Spencer | 10 May 2009 | My rating:

Ordered the two dvds from First Auditions, received the one with the Australians, but, the dvd with guys from South Africa, never made it through customs. I will never order from these guys again.