Chris | 31 Jan 2012 | My rating:

I agree with others that this site was far better when D&E were producing. The new site StraightRentBoys is now being done by D&E and it's even hotter then what they filmed after they were fired by Brokestraightboys. I like listening to David talk and interview the models because he is funny and makes you laugh with the models, but Clay is a yawn. I do give BSB a 3.0 though because it's worth the price *only* for the old videos archive.

Jason | 29 Jan 2012 | My rating:

@Anonymous
Don't know what your connection to the previous producer was, but this site is hotter than it ever has been. I have also been a member on and off since the beginning of the site. One thing I used to hate (had to fast forward past) was the interviewer, who sounded like an accountant! The guy who interviews now sounds like a dude. And Jimmy is the epitome of a straight boy! Love his face! Love his cocksure additude! This site floundered for a while, but has come back better than ever.

Anonymous | 23 Jan 2012 | My rating:

I have been a member of Broke Straight Boys, on and off, since 2006. It used to be the hottest site on the net in my opinion, they got mainly straight guys to have gay sex and love it after awhile. I know that these guys knew what they were getting themselves into and that they weren't coerced, and the director (David) always admitted if there were gay or bi guys on there, but usually they had never been in porn before and the few who had been, he was always up front with us.

The straight boys, you could tell they were straight. And usually they'd have a few scenes, do pretty much everything in some cases including getting fucked, and then they'd be done and it would be time to bring in new amateur guys. What was so great about this was not only was it hot, but the scenes were almost always funny because David got the guys to have fun with it and he'd joke around with them and get them to feel comfortable with the whole thing.

Last year, they fired David and D&E Productions from filming, and it pretty much went downhill from there.

They hired this new director who goes by the name "Clay", and a new production company to film their content, and it took like a *month* of new content before they even had any sex scenes! Everything was solo jack off scenes which very few people get into. I mean it's fine to have a new guy do a solo scene to introduce him to the viewers, but come on.

And then when they started having sex scenes, this "Clay" loser would stand there and interview them for like 20 minutes before any clothes would start to come off.

So fast forward a couple months, and the content still sucked. Not a single new scene made it onto the Members Favorites section of the website, I mean the member favorites were ALL stuff from when D&E Productions was producing the content.

And what was worse, was suddenly the guys weren't having fun with it anymore. They all claimed they HATED gay sex, and you could tell they were truly hating it. They couldn't get hard, they would all but call each other the f word, and Clay would literally dump cash on them when they were done having sex.

Eventually some of the content was getting better a lot of the time, with the exception of this straight model called Jimmy. Jimmy is hot and everything, but he's getting fat and plus you can tell he *hates* having gay sex. He literally gets his dick sucked and that's pretty much it. He does fuck sometimes, but it's always exactly the same thing. Closeups of him drilling a greased hole, and he puts no effort into it whatsoever other than in and out in and out in and out until he cums, end of scene.

But now, I feel that Broke Straight Boys has really jumped the shark.

They're crossing over models from College Dudes onto Broke Straight Boys, which just does not work. College Dudes is a completely different genre altogether, those boys are into it. They're usually hard right out of their pants, and they love kissing, making out, rubbing each other's bodys with passion, and they're just generally all very gay acting and flowery about it all.

Well BSB truly is a site about straight amateur broke boys getting it on for money. But now suddenly they're crossing over models like Rob Ryder over to Broke Straight Boys, and it just doesn't work! So now their whole fantasy about straight guys getting it on with each other has been lost, or at least really blurred. Not only that, but to me it's a rip off that they're crossing models over from one site to the other, yet you have to pay for each site separately which to me is unfair.

To make matters worse, they could have at least chosen a College Dudes model to bring over who no one has ever seen or heard of before, but instead they choose Rob Ryder. Rob Ryder has been in gay porn for years, he was a Colt model before he started working on College Dudes. He's also all over the internet you can see plenty of his content for free on various tube sites and to me that's just not fair to make you pay for a full monthly membership fee for a certain type of content (which I am happy to pay) but then they suddenly start changing the format on us and it's gone from broke straight boys to rich porn star gay boys pretending to be broke and straight and fuck each other.

I have cancelled my membership in protest, and will not rejoin again until they bring back the broke straight boys that made them famous to begin with!

Jason | 16 Jan 2012 | My rating:

I rejoined this site and am thrilled to say that it has turned around recently. They again have the hottest guys on the internet: Conner, AJ, Chad, Jimmy, CJ, and Darren. Great quality videos. Definitely worth the subscription!

Bob Hill | 07 Jan 2012 | My rating:

Great sites, hundreds of video's. One of the best sites you'll find on the Internet.

patrick lee | 24 Aug 2011 | My rating:

I left after "mike robbins" was declared dead by the site owners. They refused to explain how he died. We always insisted that we didn't want any personal info, address D.O.B. real name, we just wanted to know how? That's all! Even strangers in his home town could read the local paper and find out how he died. People that he barely knew could go to his funeral and pay their last respects. We didn't even want that, just an explanation as to how he died, the cause of death. THAT'S ALL! We were brushed aside like we didn't have the right to know. I'm not speaking about legal rights here, at all. Just common human compassion. For people that had become this young man's friend, that he himself encouraged in the members forum, he knew alot of us by name age gender and location. That's more than half of his home town, and all they had to do was listen to their local news. I wish someone anyone with the time talent and money could and would look into this, and maybe bring closure to alot of his friends that knew and loved him very much..We can hope!!

Pavel | 25 Jul 2011 | My rating:

First the good. The $3.00 trial membership gives you full site access for 3 days. But now the bad. This used to be my all time favorite site because the scenes were hot, the guys in them I had never seen before, and I liked the humor in the scenes like in the interviews and stuff. But once they went to the new format, I noticed the guys are all becoming professional gay porn models that I've seen most of them on other sites before seeing them on Broke Straight Boys. I don't consider that a good thing because you can see these guys all over the net on other sites. I liked it a lot better when the new guys came on you never saw them anywhere before. It's becomming to professional, no more amateur qualities to it like there used to be. Hot sex scenes are on every porn site, this site isn't special anymore like it used to be. I hope they go back to the amateur straight boys site they used to be instead of professional gay porn models like it is now.

jesse h | 03 Jul 2011 | My rating:

I agree with the previous couple contents. This site has gone DOWNHILL since they changed directors. The scenes used to be so hot and it was original. Just liked the comments below said, you can find this exact same stuff for free on like gaytube.com or something. It's just plain old vanilla sex.
DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND GO SOMEWHERE ELSE. There are better sites out there for the same price or cheaper.

Stephen | 04 Jun 2011 | My rating:

I used to love this site, been a member for years, but I tried to cancel after the new company started directing the scenes and now they're boring and no longer hot.

But what I hate about this site, is you can't cancel anymore without calling them to cancel. They removed the cancel option from the site, you now have to call customer service to cancel.

I guess too many members are quitting their memberships so they have to resort to making it as difficult as possible to cancel.

They need to bring back the old crew and make it hot again, but I won't rejoin until they make it easy to cancel again.

Dave | 01 Jun 2011 | My rating:

Used to love this site, but since they changed directors and production companies brokestraightboys has gone straight downhill. There hasn't been a hot scene since the new company took over, I just cancelled my membership for the first time in 4 years.

Former Member | 12 May 2011 | My rating:

I used to be a continuous member of BrokeStraightBoys since its inception in 2006. But I cancelled after they changed directors, it has really gone downhill. The scenes are now boring, there is no passion between the guys, the scenarios are very boring, predictable, and scripted. What used to be a fun and hot site has turned into a very boring, cookie cutter site. The type of content they're cranking out now can be seen for free elsewhere without having to pay for a membership.


It's also rather strange how the new director seems very anti gay, and is constantly making anti gay comments and remarks and he's also into really weird stuff like closeups of dirty feet and things like that.


Not sure where they felt they were going when they decided to change directors, but they turned what used to be a fun and hot site into a very boring and stupid one.


Since the new director and format change, I wouldn't visit Broke Straight Boys if it was free now.

Mike | 10 May 2011 | My rating:

NOTICE TO EVERYONE! This site has changed Directors and has gone to utter shit. The new Director is homophobic and the stories go from absurd ('straight' guys playing footsie) to down right patronizing and homophobic. Not only that but the new models looked like they are fresh out of prison.


To make matters worse, they make it VERY difficult to cancel. There is no link to cancel on the member's homepage for when you sign up by Netbilling and it seems they purposefully make it as difficult as possible. I had to search high and low to find a way to cancel until finally I saw someone posted about the same problem on their message board (but the owner still didn't fix the problem).

James | 26 Oct 2010 | My rating:

This site got really hot after they started filming in hd! But lately it's getting really boring, they keep using the same guys in every scene. And since the site updates 3 times a week, seeing the same 3 guys in every scene is getting really boring.

One of those guys (Leon) is nasty, you can even see his dirty feet in one of the scenes so it's like he doesn't even shower. Plus his hair is greasy and nasty, not to mention he has so many pimples you can tell he probably only showers once a week.

Mike Robbins (another over used actor who is in every single scene) never does anything more than get his dick sucked, or fuck. He never kisses or anything, and that's boring. Plus he looks like trailer trash with all the cheap tattoos all over his body. Hey I like ink as much as the next guy, but c'mon people it has to at least look good and be done well or you just look like trailer trash. You have to spend more than 5 bucks on a tattoo otherwise it just looks stupid.

i also hate that braden guy, he's been on a ton of other sites too so you can see him for free just do a google search of him and you won't even have to pay a monthly membership to see him in porn. plus he's always coughing and hacking, so he must have been smoking since he was 5. I also hate his attitude, he really sucks at fucking lol!

hopefully they'll quit using these 3 clowns in the scenes and once they get some new guys on there i'm sure it will start getting hot again!

james

William | 17 Aug 2010 | My rating:

Used to be a member of this site but it gets old after a while. Plus the guy that talks on the videos sound so gay. lots of the guys on there you can tell are not gay at all please straight guys really don't do all that they might get their cocks sucked but thats about it I don't think any straight guy would fuck a guy just like that. its a joke the whole site is.Not the best site

Andrew | 24 Oct 2009 | My rating:

Liked this site very much, although some of the guys are so obviously NOT straight it is laughable. Still, there are enough who appear straight that it is hot. I remember one of the earlier episodes where one guy was so disgusted by getting his dick sucked by another guy that the video was not erotic at all he couldn't even get hard) and should not have been put up by the director.